Evaluation of an intervention to increase non-traditional career interests and career-related self-efficacy among middle-school adolescents
Introduction
Over the last several decades, research has quite consistently demonstrated significant gender differences in the development and expression of young people’s occupational interests (Swanson & Gore, 2000). For example, researchers have shown that children from an early age have strong sex-typed occupational preferences, with boys demonstrating more rigid sex typing than girls (Helwig, 1998, Helwig, 2002; Trice, Hughes, Odom, Woods, & McClellan, 1995). Middle school and high school aged adolescents’ interests and efficacy to pursue specific occupations have been shown to correspond to demonstrated differences in men’s and women’s employment patterns across Holland Themes (i.e., more men work in realistic, investigative, and enterprising occupations, and more women work in artistic, social, and conventional occupations) (Gottfredson & Lapan, 1997; Lapan, Adams, Turner, & Hinkelman, 2000; Lapan, Hinkelman, Adams, & Turner, 1999; Turner & Lapan, 2002). Middle school, junior-high, and high school aged adolescents’ vocational aspirations, expectations, and preferences have been shown to be associated with their sex-type ratings of occupations, with boys showing significantly higher preferences than girls for more prestigious and higher paying careers (Armstrong & Crombie, 2000; Brown, 1997; Davey & Stoppard, 1993; Lapan & Jingeleski, 1992). College age young people have been shown to express greater interests in, efficacy for, and commitment to occupations that are dominated by members of their own gender (Betz & Schifano, 2000; Chung, 2002; Einarsdottir & Rounds, 2000).
Gender differences are a critical factor to the extent that they lead young people to pursue certain career paths at the expense of others. One theory that describes how such gender differences develop is circumscription and compromise theory (CCT; Gottfredson, 1981, Gottfredson, 2002; Gottfredson & Lapan, 1997). According to CCT, young people’s occupational aspirations (and interests) are shaped by their socialization experiences. By the age of nine, children begin to circumscribe their vocational interests according to their understanding of the gender-appropriateness of various occupations. This circumscription of aspirations means that by early adolescence, when interests have crystallized, young people have decreased their “zone of acceptable alternatives,” which demarcates those occupations that the individual considers preferable from those that are ruled out as incompatible with how one comes to understand oneself. This rejection of whole segments of the occupational world leads to a narrowing of the occupational options that young people consider and explore, and for which they prepare.
Some authors have addressed how to change adolescents’ career interests. For example, both Prediger and Noeth (1979), and O’Brien, Dukstein, Jackson, Tomlinson, and Kamatuka (1999) demonstrated that using the results of adolescents’ career interest inventories to engage them in career exploration yielded an increase in the number of careers young people considered, and improved the congruence between their career interests and potential career choices. However, although there is compelling evidence in the vocational literature that gender-typing of occupations limits adolescents’ occupational options, little research has been done to explore how to intervene to address the issue of occupational gender-typing among boys and girls.
Some theorists (Gottfredson & Lapan, 1997) have hypothesized that interventions which increase young people’s career-related self-efficacy may reverse, at least in part, their circumscription of occupations by broadening their zone of acceptable alternatives. Given the need for research in this area, the purpose of the present study was to investigate the effects of a computerized career intervention for middle school adolescents designed to increase their career awareness, their efficacy to engage in career planning and exploration, their efficacy to engage in educational planning for specific occupations, and their vocational interests in non-traditional careers. The intervention, Mapping Vocational Challenges (MVC; Lapan & Turner, 1997, 2000), includes educational and occupational information about a variety of career pathways, a self-assessment activity that focuses on the influence of gender-role stereotyping on adolescents’ interests, efficacy, perceived parent support, and valuing of various careers, and an interpretive report that can be used by career and guidance counselors to facilitate adolescents’ understanding and use of their own assessment results.
We hypothesized that use of the MVC would increase young adolescents’ career planning and exploration self-efficacy, educational and vocational development self-efficacy, and career interests in non-traditional occupations (i.e., for boys A, S, and C and for girls R, I, and E) across Holland’s occupational themes. Specifically, we hypothesized that there would be significant differences at pre-test in the career interests and efficacy of adolescents, as a function of gender (Hypothesis 1); that there would be significant increases at post-test in career planning and exploration efficacy, and educational and vocational development efficacy for both boys and girls in the experimental group but not in the control group (Hypothesis 2); and, that there would be significant increases at post-test in non-traditional career interests for both boys and girls in the experimental group but not in the control group (Hypothesis 3).
Section snippets
Participants
Participants were 160 middle school students from two ethnically diverse public middle schools in a lower-middle to middle-class neighborhood in a mid-sized, midwestern community. They were assigned to treatment (n = 107) and delayed-treatment control (n = 53) groups using a quasi-experimental, non-equivalent groups design. In a non-equivalent groups design, intact groups with similar characteristics (i.e., students from the same grades, from the same type of school, and from a similar
Results
Hypothesis 1 stated that there would be significant differences in the career interests and efficacy of adolescents at pre-test, as a function of gender. To guard against selection bias, we first tested for differences between the experimental and control groups’ UNIACT-R, CPEE, and EVDS pre-test scores using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA). We found no differences in these scores as a function of treatment group (F = .067–3.85, all p’s > .05).
Then to test Hypothesis 1, we conducted a series
Discussion
The purpose of this study was to describe a career development intervention, Mapping Vocational Challenges (MVC), and to assess its utility in increasing middle-school adolescents’ career planning and exploration efficacy, educational and vocational development efficacy, and interests in non-traditional careers. Results demonstrated that the MVC is a useful career intervention activity that can increase adolescents’ efficacy in these career development areas, and increase interests in
Limitations and suggestions for future research
This study is limited in that only short-term gains (after 1 week) were measured. In addition, several of the measured gains in efficacy and interests were small. This calls into question the practical significance of our study results, but it is important to note that the effect sizes found in our study were not dissimilar to those reported by Brown and Ryan Krane (2000), and Whiston et al. (1998). These researchers found that career interventions yield an overall effect size of d = .34 and d =
References (44)
- et al.
Compromises in adolescents’ occupational aspirations and expectations from Grades 8 to 10
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2000) - et al.
Evaluation of an intervention to increase realistic self-efficacy and interests in college women
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2000) - et al.
The effects of a nontraditional role-modeling intervention on sex typing of occupational preferences and career salience in adolescent females
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(1985) - et al.
Some factors affecting the occupational expectations of female adolescents
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(1993) - et al.
Application of three dimensions of vocational interests to the Strong Interest Inventory
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(2000) - et al.
Effectiveness of a brief counseling intervention in stimulating vocational exploration
Journal of Vocational Behavior
(1979) Sex differences in the career development of urban African American Adolescents
Journal of Career Development
(1997)- et al.
Four (or five) sessions and a cloud of dust: Old assumptions and new observations about career counseling
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Department of Labor (1999). Occupational outlook handbook, 1998–1999 Edition....
Career decision-making self-efficacy and career commitment: Gender and ethnic differences among college students
Journal of Career Development
(2002)
Enhancing rural female adolescents’ awareness of nontraditional careers
Career Development Quarterly
Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
An evaluation of a treatment to expand the career perceptions of junior high school girls
School Counselor
Ohio Vocational Interest Survey, manual for interpreting
Applying educational research: A practical guide
Circumscription and compromise: A developmental theory of occupational aspirations
Journal of Counseling Psychology
Gottfredson’s Theory of Circumscription, Compromise, and Self-Creation
Assessing gender-based circumscription of occupational aspirations
Journal of Career Assessment
Missouri comprehensive guidance survey
Gender-role stereotyping: Testing theory with a longitudinal sample
Sex Roles
Sex and developmental differences by complexity of functions of occupational aspirations of school children across ten years
Psychological Reports
Research design in counseling
Cited by (85)
Children's approaches to solving puzzles in videogames
2024, International Journal of Child-Computer InteractionChinese high school students' career development: Associations with academic self-efficacy and motivation
2024, Journal of Applied Developmental PsychologyEffectiveness of a web-based acceptance and commitment therapy program for adolescent career preparation: A randomized controlled trial
2021, Journal of Vocational BehaviorCitation Excerpt :For example, Koivisto et al. (2011) showed for a community sample of youth that a one-week workshop program intervention successfully promoted ninth graders' career choice preparedness and positive attitude towards career planning. Web-based interventions to promote exploring career options and searching for career-related information have also been found to be useful tools in career counseling for adolescents and university students (Betz & Borgen, 2009; Fowkes & McWhirter, 2007; Tirpak & Schlosser, 2013; Turner & Lapan, 2005). However, most previous preventive interventions (for a review, see Lent, 2013) have been educational with the emphasis on promoting capabilities in information seeking, crystallizing vocational interests, and promoting effective career decision-making.
Entrepreneurship education 2-in-1: Helping young Bulgarians become more entrepreneurial in a 10-month parallel-group randomized trial
2023, Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship