Review EssayThe local food environment and diet: A systematic review
Introduction
The body of literature on the local food environment and its effects on health has been growing, particularly in response to evidence of “food deserts” pocketing the US urban landscape (Michimi and Wimberly, 2010, Zenk et al., 2005). Yet, to date, there has not been a comprehensive review of the relationship between the local food environment and dietary outcomes. Previous food environment review articles have generally fallen into two categories. First, review articles have focused their discussion on disparities in access to healthy foods, including the existence of food deserts and neighborhood characteristics associated with food deserts (Larson et al., 2009, Walker et al., 2010). Other articles exploring the effects of food deserts have touched upon diet while focusing primarily on obesity as an outcome (Black and Macinko, 2008, Casagrande et al., 2009, Ford and Dzewaltowski, 2008, Holsten, 2009, Lovasi et al., 2009). For the most part, these reviews present comprehensive and theoretically sound discussions of the environmental determinants of obesity. Yet there has been relatively little discussion specifically devoted to what is conceivably the primary mechanism through which “obesogenic” settings operate – namely, the food environment–diet relationship.
Studies exploring the food environment–diet relationship have used a wide variety of methodologies to measure the degree of food access for study participants. In the past two decades, the increased use of Geographic Information Systems (GIS) technology has resulted in an outpouring of exposure assessment techniques (McKinnon et al., 2009). These measures commonly use store density (using buffer distances), or proximity to the nearest food store to operationalize food access (Charreire et al., 2010), although finding appropriate and consistent criteria for defining geographic boundaries has proved challenging (Charreire et al., 2010). Another common objective method for assessing food access is store audits, in which researchers visit stores and estimate the shelf-space occupied by certain foods in each store, or assess product variety or food prices within stores. Validated store audit measures, such as the Nutrition Environment Measure Survey (NEMS), have often been used to evaluate such store features (Glanz et al., 2007), although such measures have been used infrequently in studies linking food environments to health outcomes.
Still others studies have relied on respondent-based perceived measures to capture the food environment, including perceived availability and accessibility of food or food stores. Though uncommon, a few studies have used both a perceived and an objective measure in their study – for example, the availability of healthy food in the neighborhood and store density. In general, the proportion of studies using perceived measures of the food environment is small compared with those that use GIS-based methods; by 2007, GIS-based measures of the food environment outnumbered interview/questionnaire measures 57 to 10 (McKinnon et al., 2009), and the use of GIS measures is only likely to increase if current trends continue (Charreire et al., 2010). Undoubtedly, because of extensive variation in the operationalization of the local food environment, many measurement challenges remain unaddressed (Lytle, 2009) (Fig. 1).
Despite major measurement inconsistencies, previous review articles have yet to examine comprehensively how the food environment–diet study results have differed according to the method of exposure assessment. One previous review article sorted results by exposure assessment type, but examined only the fast food environment (Fraser et al., 2010). A recent set of two reviews sought to overview different indicators of the food environment, but one included only GIS-based measures (Charreire et al., 2010); the other examined only non-geographic measures and stopped short of linking the different exposure measures to actual dietary outcomes (Kelly et al., 2011).
A theoretical framework for conceptualizing the local food environment: Beyond the strictly methodological task of selecting the best exposure assessment technique lays a more theoretical question concerning the very definition of food access. Frequently, food environment conceptualizations have been divided into the community food environment and the consumer food environment (Glanz et al., 2005), drawing a useful distinction between the distribution of food sources within a community and what consumers encounter while inside their local retailers. Several previous articles have also begun to explore even more subtle conceptualizations of the food environment (Charreire et al., 2010, McKinnon et al., 2009), including the different dimensions of access that food environment measures have actually tapped into. Although a complete list of such dimensions has never been compiled, it has been suggested (Charreire et al., 2010) that one way of conceptualizing food access dimensions is by adapting a model of access proposed by Penchansky and Thomas, who outlined 5 dimensions relevant in the healthcare setting (Penchansky and Thomas, 1981). These dimensions include availability, accessibility, affordability, acceptability, and accommodation.
The first three are the most obviously familiar in the existing body of literature. Availability refers to the adequacy of the supply of healthy food; examples in the food environment might include the presence of certain types of restaurants near people's homes, or the number of places to buy produce. The dimension of accessibility may be more inherently geographic, as it refers to the location of the food supply and ease of getting to that location. Travel time and distance are key measures of accessibility. Affordability refers to food prices and people's perceptions of worth relative to the cost, and is often measured by store audits of specific foods, or regional price indices. Acceptability refers to people's attitudes about attributes of their local food environment, and whether or not the given supply of products meets their personal standards. As an attitudinal variable, it may be ideally measured by surveying participants; however, there have been a few creative attempts to estimate food acceptability by more objective means – for instance, by having store auditors assign food quality scores to produce. Accommodation, or how well local food sources accept and adapt to local residents' needs, is the final dimension of access. It is largely open to exploration in the current literature but could, for example, refer to store hours and types of payment accepted.
The primary aim of this paper is to evaluate the existing body of literature on the relationship between the local food environment and diet, with particular attention placed on the method of characterizing of the food environment. The secondary aim of this study is to explore the variety of conceptual definitions of “food access” within this body of literature. The relationship between food environments and diet will be diced according to different quantitative assessments of the food environment, as well as the different dimensions of access that could underlie each measure. Finally, this paper will identify understudied dimensions of “food access”, and make recommendations for future directions for the optimal study and improvement of food environments.
Section snippets
Methods
This paper is a review of 38 papers on the food environment and diet. Articles were retrieved through a systematic keyword search in Web of Science and supplemented via a “snowball method” in which references from relevant articles were reviewed and selected if they met inclusion criteria. Keyword searches included words pertaining to diet (diet⁎, fruit⁎ and vegetable⁎, nutrition⁎, consumption, intake) and at least one other term pertaining to access (access⁎, availability, affordability,
Results
In total, 38 studies met inclusion criteria and were included in this review (Table 1). Most studies examined an adult population, but seven (Beydoun et al., 2008, Beydoun et al., 2011, Caldwell et al., 2009, Jago et al., 2007, Leung et al., 2010, Powell and Han, 2011, Timperio et al., 2008) included children or adolescents. Studies overwhelmingly used a cross-sectional design, but three were natural experiments or interventions that compared pre- and post-test dietary measures (Caldwell et
Discussion
Overview: This review of 38 studies of the food environment found moderate evidence in support of the causal hypothesis that neighborhood food environments influence dietary health. Yet, even though the number of studies on the subject is substantial, overall reproducibility was lacking because of the absence of an “industry standard” for measuring local food access.
Perceived measures of availability were consistently related to multiple healthy dietary outcomes. On the other hand, GIS-based
Recommendations
Refining the measures used to capture multiple dimensions of food access should be a top priority for researchers conducting studies on the food environment–diet relationship. Based on this review of 38 studies of the food environment, we make the following recommendations for future research:
- (1)
Standardize and validate measures: The field is in need of more standardized measures for assessing the food environment. Studies using buffer distance-based measures only occasionally provided a rationale
Conclusion
The assessment of the local food environment is likely to be the topic of a great number of studies in the coming years, if current trends continue (McKinnon et al., 2009). While many measurement challenges remain, only through accurate and comprehensive assessments of the food environment–diet relationship can researchers provide insight into how the local environment may be altered to elicit actual improvements in dietary health. Ultimately, the combination of rigorous spatial and store audit
References (67)
- et al.
The association of fast food, fruit and vegetable prices with dietary intakes among US adults: Is there modification by family income?
Social Science & Medicine
(2008) - et al.
Food prices are associated with dietary quality, fast food consumption, and body mass index among U.S. children and adolescents
The Journal of Nutrition
(2011) - et al.
Built environment and health behaviors among African Americans: a systematic review
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
(2009) - et al.
Community-Level Comparisons Between the Grocery Store Environment and Individual Dietary Practices
Preventive Medicine
(1991) - et al.
Availability of healthy foods and dietary patterns: the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
(2009) - et al.
Stepping towards causation: Do built environments or neighborhood and travel preferences explain physical activity, driving, and obesity?
Social Science and Medicine
(2007) - et al.
Nutrition environment measures survey in stores (NEMS-S): development and evaluation
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
(2007) - et al.
Associations between neighborhood availability and individual consumption of dark-green and orange vegetables among ethnically diverse adults in Detroit
Journal of the American Dietetic Association
(2011) - et al.
Local food outlets, weight status, and dietary intake: associations in children aged 9–10 years
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
(2011) - et al.
Measuring local food environments: an overview of available methods and measures
Health & Place
(2011)
Proximity of supermarkets is positively associated with diet quality index for pregnancy
Preventive Medicine
Measuring the food environment: state of the science
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
Measures of the food environment a compilation of the literature, 1990–2007
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
Supermarkets, other food stores, and obesity – The atherosclerosis risk in communities study
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
Neighborhood food store availability in relation to food intake in young Japanese women
Nutrition (Burbank, Los Angeles County, Calif.)
No meaningful association of neighborhood food store availability with dietary intake, body mass index, or waist circumference in young Japanese women
Nutrition Research (New York, N.Y.)
Dietary patterns are associated with biochemical markers of inflammation and endothelial activation in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA)
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
Are immigrant enclaves healthy places to live? The Multi-ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis
Social Science and Medicine
Interactive effects of reward sensitivity and residential fast-food restaurant exposure on fast-food consumption
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
A national study of the association between neighbourhood access to fast-food outlets and the diet and weight of local residents
Health and Place
Do “food deserts” influence fruit and vegetable consumption?--A cross-sectional study
Appetite
The costs of food at home and away from home and consumption patterns among U.S. adolescents
The Journal of Adolescent Health: Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine
Food prices and fruit and vegetable consumption among young American adults
Health and Place
Measuring potential access to food stores and food-service places in rural areas in the U.S. American
Journal of Preventive Medicine
Children's fruit and vegetable intake: associations with the neighbourhood food environment
Preventive Medicine
Socioeconomic disadvantage and the purchase of takeaway food: a multilevel analysis
Appetite
Disparities and access to healthy food in the United States: A review of food deserts literature
Health and Place
Shopping for fruits and vegetables. Food and retail qualities of importance to low-income households at the grocery store
Appetite
Why do some socioeconomically disadvantaged women eat better than others? An investigation of the personal, social and environmental correlates of fruit and vegetable consumption
Appetite
Fruit and vegetable intake in African Americans - Income and store characteristics
American Journal of Preventive Medicine
Neighborhoods and obesity
Nutrition Reviews
Neighbourhood fruit and vegetable availability and consumption: the role of small food stores in an urban environment
Public Health Nutrition
Perceived access to fruits and vegetables associated with increased consumption
Public Health Nutrition
Cited by (944)
Perspective: Nutrition Health Disparities Framework: A Model to Advance Health Equity
2024, Advances in NutritionA natural experiment: The opening of a supermarket in a public housing community and impacts on children's dietary patterns
2024, Preventive Medicine ReportsThe Influence of the School Neighborhood Food Retail Environment on Unhealthy Food Purchasing Behaviors Among Adolescents: A Systematic Review
2024, Journal of Nutrition Education and BehaviorAn Increase in Food Insecurity Correlated with an Increase in Plasma Triglycerides among Latinx Children
2024, Journal of Nutrition