Cognitive-behavior therapy vs exposure therapy in the treatment of PTSD in refugees
Introduction
The lifetime prevalence of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in community samples that were not at risk for PTSD ranged from 1.0 to 1.3% (Davidson, Hughes, Blazer & George, 1991; Helzer, Robins & McEvoy, 1987; Perkonigg, Kessler, Storz & Wittchen, 2000). Current prevalence rates of PTSD in different traumatized refugee groups varied between 10.7 and 86% depending upon the type of sample, the type of traumatic events, and the refugee groups that were studied (Carlson & Rosser-Hogan, 1991, Cheung, 1994, Gorst-Unsworth & Goldenberg, 1998, Kinzie et al., 1990; Lavik, Hauff, Skrondal & Solberg, 1996). Some traumatized refugee groups seem to run a much higher risk to develop PTSD than individuals exposed to civilian traumas. For example, Carlson and Rosser-Hogan (1991) found an 86% current prevalence rate of PTSD in a randomly selected community sample of Cambodian refugees in the USA, which is about nine times higher than the 9.7% prevalence rate of current PTSD that was found in a nationally representative sample of civilian female assault victims (Resnick, Kilpatrick, Dansky, Saunders & Best, 1993).
Foa and Meadows (1997) stated that the most vigorously studied psychological treatments for PTSD are the cognitive-behavioral interventions. In their literature review of psychological treatment outcome studies for PTSD they concluded that controlled studies support the efficacy of imaginal and in vivo exposure and stress inoculation training (SIT) for the treatment of PTSD. Also, they stated that cognitive processing therapy has shown promising initial findings, but that it awaits more rigorously controlled studies before its efficacy can be determined.
Only one study has used formal PTSD measures according to the DSM-criteria in order to evaluate the efficacy of a psychological treatment for a group of refugees with PTSD. Weine, Kulenovic, Pavkovic and Gibbons (1998) evaluated testimony psychotherapy (Agger & Jensen, 1990, Cienfuegos & Monelli, 1983) in 20 adult Bosnian refugees. They received an average of six weekly sessions (range=4–8) of treatment, each session lasting approximately 90 min. The rate of PTSD diagnosis decreased from 100% before treatment to 75% after treatment, 70% at 2-month follow-up and 53% at 6-month follow-up. The authors state that one overlap between testimony psychotherapy and cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is imaginal exposure (Weine et al., 1998; p. 1725). This study indicates that exposure therapy might be an effective treatment for refugees with PTSD. However, due to the lack of randomized treatment studies the relative effectiveness of psychological treatments for PTSD in refugees cannot yet be determined.
According to the cognitive theory of PTSD (Ehlers & Steil, 1995) the traumatized individual interprets the occurrence of the intrusive recollections in a catastrophic way. Catastrophic interpretations of intrusive recollections may recharge the PTSD-symptoms despite occasional habituation after prolonged exposure (PE) to trauma cues. It is hypothesized that a CBT that targets both catastrophic interpretations of intrusions and avoidance behaviors in PTSD will be significantly more effective than exposure treatment that only focuses on avoidance behaviors.
In this study CBT is compared with exposure therapy (E) as treatments for PTSD in refugees. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first randomized treatment outcome study with a refugee sample. It is hypothesized that both treatments will significantly reduce PTSD symptoms. Furthermore, it is predicted that CBT will be more effective than E because it targets catastrophic interpretations of intrusions in addition to avoidance behaviors. Secondly, it is predicted that anxious and depressive symptomatology will be significantly reduced by both treatments, but that CBT will be more effective than E. Thirdly, it is hypothesized that the quality of life and cognitive schemas of assumptions about the world will be improved by both treatments. Finally, it is predicted that these results will be maintained at a 6-month follow-up.
Section snippets
Subjects and design
Refugee patients (n=20) fulfilling the DSM-IV (APA, 1994) criteria for PTSD served as Ss in the study. They were recruited through referrals from psychiatric units in the Stockholm County, and from the Center for tortured and traumatized refugees at the Karolinska hospital in Stockholm.
Attrition
Four clients, one in the E-group and three in the CBT-group, were excluded at an early stage of treatment. The client from the E-group and two of the clients from the CBT-group missed a third consecutive appointment session 2, 3 or 4, and after that they were excluded from the treatment. One client from the CBT-group was excluded due to hostile behaviors towards the therapist during the first session. There were no significant differences between the four clients who dropped out of the
Discussion
The aims of this study were to evaluate the effects of E and CBT for traumatized refugees with PTSD, both immediately afterwards and 6 months after treatment. The results of this study showed that E and CBT decreased the patients' PTSD symptoms, generalized anxiety and depression with 43–60% after treatment. In addition to that, the patients quality of life and cognitive schemas of the self, the world and meaningfulness increased significantly after treatment. These results were largely
References (42)
- et al.
Psychometric properties of the Beck Depression Inventory: twenty-five years of evaluation
Clinical Psychology Review
(1988) - et al.
Applied relaxation vs. cognitive behavior therapy in the treatment of panic disorder
Behaviour Research and Therapy
(1995) - et al.
Testimony as ritual and evidence in psychotherapy for political refugees
Journal of Traumatic Stress
(1990) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
(1987)Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
(1994)- et al.
An inventory for measuring clinical anxiety
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
(1988) - et al.
An inventory for measuring depression
Archives of General Psychiatry
(1961) - et al.
Clinician-administered PTSD scale for DSM-IV
(1997) - et al.
The development of a clinician-administered PTSD scale
Journal of Traumatic Stress
(1995) - et al.
Anxiety disorders interview schedule for DSM-IV
(1994)
Trauma experiences, posttraumatic stress, dissociation, and depression in Cambodian refugees
American Journal of Psychiatry
Posttraumatic stress disorder among Cambodian refugees in New Zealand
International Journal of Social Psychiatry
The testimony of political repression as a therapeutic instrument
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry
Post-traumatic stress disorder in the community: an epidemiological study
Psychological Medicine
Psychological interventions
Maintenance of intrusive memories in posttraumatic stress disorder: a cognitive approach
Behavioral and Cognitive Psychotherapy
A comparison of exposure therapy, stress inoculation training, and their combination for reducing posttraumatic stress disorder in female assault victims
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Psychosocial treatments for post-traumatic stress disorder: a critical review
Reliability and validity of a brief instrument for assessing post-traumatic stress disorder
Journal of Traumatic Stress
Treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder in rape victims: a comparison between cognitive-behavioral procedures and counseling
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Cited by (257)
The longitudinal influence of cyberbullying victimization on depression and posttraumatic stress symptoms: The mediation role of rumination
2020, Archives of Psychiatric NursingProlonged Exposure for PTSD: Impact on emotions
2020, Emotion in Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: Etiology, Assessment, Neurobiology, and TreatmentMood dysregulation: Beyond the bipolar spectrum
2023, Mood Dysregulation: Beyond the Bipolar SpectrumProlonged contextual fear memory in AMPA receptor palmitoylation-deficient mice
2022, Neuropsychopharmacology