Which resources pay for treatment? A model for estimating the informal economy of health

doi:10.1016/0277-9536(95)00412-2

Social Science & Medicine

Volume 42, Issue 5, March 1996, Pages 671-679

https://doi.org/10.1016/0277-9536(95)00412-2 Get rights and content

Abstract

The model proposed is a means for (i) documenting the resources a woman deploys to choose, seek, find, get and pay for treatment; (ii) comparing what she has/does with a neighbour facing similar symptoms and problems, and (iii) understanding which difference between them makes most difference to the way they manage illness. In a narrow economic perspective, only tangible items with easily enumerated values are called resources, and only the formal economy counts. This model allows assessment of the value of both formal and informal resources in the household system. It will not establish the absolute or market worth of households in the sample, but does offer a framework for comparing households which have the same access to a given set of treatment options when faced with the same symptoms. Its application improves the possibility of understanding which resources, or combinations of resources, make most difference to a household's capacity to seek and get the treatment it has decided it needs. The paper is one element of a multi-layered and multi-disciplinary study of ‘The Informal Economy of Health in African Cities’. The overall project aims are (i) to map the cultural, infrastructural and clinical factors affecting the treatment-seeking behaviour of women in low-income urban areas; (ii) to compare their effect(s) on the management of symptoms of adult veneral infection (STD) and crisis symptoms in children under five. The project mapped the social context of illness management in a district of Kampala. Important dimensions of that context are: the infrastructure of the area, and the treatment options available in or around it; women's assessments of how good/kind/shameful/private/feasible/appropriate those options are, and the social and physical signs which trigger the conclusion that a symptom is ‘serious enough’ to need treatment outside the home in the first place. The focus here is the value of resources mobilized after the ‘serious enough’ assessment has been made. (For a wider picture, see Kampala Women Getting By. James Currey, London, 1996.

References (40)

P. Berman et al.
The household production of health: integrating social science perspectives on micro-level health determinants
Soc. Sci. Med.
(1994)
S. Wallman and Associates
Kampala Women Getting By: Wellbeing in the Time of AIDS
(1996)
Comparison was necessary to test the hypothesis that the stigma of STD entails patterns of treatment seeking different...
The parish/township/RC2 area Kamwokya II in...
S. Wallman
Sex and death: the AIDS crisis in social and cultural context
J. AIDS
(1988)
The ‘informal economy’ is also called the ‘second’, ‘black’ or ‘hidden’...
P. Harding et al.
The Myth of the Hidden Economy
S. Wallman
J.I. Gershuny
Social Innovation and the Division of Labour
(1983)
Treatment Sources Survey
(Oct–Nov. 1993)

S. Wallman

Eight London Households

In this multi-disciplinary forum, it may be useful to note the qualitative:quantitative opposition does not have the...

Within economics, to invest is ‘to forego a resource in the immediate/short term to realize a return in the medium/long...

The assumption ceteris paribus, which commonly underlies economics’ models, of course refers to...

This score is the ratio of all members of the household over the number of earners among them—i.e. the Household...

M. Sahlins

Stone Age Economics

(1974)

R. Paine

Anthropology beyond routine: cultural alternatives for the handling of the unexpected

Int. J. Moral Soc. Stud.

(1992)

F.G. Bailey

Caste and the Economic Frontier

(1957)

R. Firth

Degrees of intelligibility

Cited by (25)

Narrative review of current context of malaria and management strategies in Uganda (Part I)
2015, Acta Tropica
Citation Excerpt :
Among those who do access these facilities, they often do so when home or private sector treatments fail or when complications occur (Rutebemberwa et al., 2009a). Reasons for seeking care outside public facilities are several: geographical barriers such as distance, financial costs associated with travel and time away from work, demands of domestic life which makes timely access difficult, and general dissatisfaction with public facilities which include inconvenient hours, long wait times, inadequate staffing, poor quality of service, failure to adequately stock drugs, charging of unofficial fees in spite of user fee removal, and poor attitudes among health workers who reportedly become readily impatient when asked for clarifications (Amuge et al., 2004; Baume et al., 2000; Kemble et al., 2006; Kizito et al., 2012; Medicines for Malaria Venture, 2008; Nsungwa-Sabiiti et al., 2005; Nuwaha, 2002; Rutebemberwa et al., 2009b; Tanner and Vlassoff, 1998; Wallman and Baker, 1996; Winstanley et al., 2002, 2004; World Health Organization (WHO), 2004; Zurovac et al., 2005). Of those who do access care from public facilities, care is often substandard despite implementation of national malaria control protocols in the public sector (Bastiaens et al., 2014; Littrell et al., 2011).
In accordance with international targets, the Uganda National Malaria Control Strategic Plan established specific targets to be achieved by 2010. For children under five, this included increasing the number of children sleeping under mosquito nets and those receiving a first-line antimalarial to 85%, and decreasing case fatality to 2%. This narrative review offers contextual information relevant to malaria management in Uganda since the advent of artemisinin combination therapy (ACT) as first-line antimalarial treatment in 2004. A comprehensive search using key words and phrases was conducted using the web search engines Google and Google Scholar, as well as the databases of PubMed, ERIC, EMBASE, CINAHL, OvidSP (MEDLINE), PSYC Info, Springer Link, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), and Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews were searched. A total of 147 relevant international and Ugandan literature sources meeting the inclusion criteria were included. This review provides an insightful understanding on six topic areas: global and local priorities, malarial pathology, disease burden, malaria control, treatment guidelines for uncomplicated malaria, and role of the health system in accessing antimalarial medicines. Plasmodium falciparum remains the most common cause of malaria in Uganda, with children under five being most vulnerable due to their underdeveloped immunity. While international efforts to scale up malaria control measures have resulted in considerable decline in malaria incidence and mortality in several regions of sub-Saharan Africa, this benefit has yet to be substantiated for Uganda. At the local level, key initiatives have included implementation of a new antimalarial drug policy in 2004 and strengthening of government health systems and programs. Examples of such programs include removal of user fees, training of frontline health workers, providing free ACT from government systems and subsidized ACT from licensed private outlets, and introduction of the integrated community case management program to bring diagnostics and treatment for malaria, pneumonia and diarrhea closer to the community. However despite notable efforts, Uganda is far from achieving its 2010 targets. Several challenges in the delivery of care and treatment remain, with those most vulnerable and living in rural settings remaining at greatest risk from malaria morbidity and mortality.
Willingness to pay for public health services in rural Central Java, Indonesia: Methodological considerations when using the contingent valuation method
2014, Social Science and Medicine
Citation Excerpt :
We believe that this is because we used debt to differentiate WTP from WTPpayable. Respondents set household priorities and changed their expenditure patterns according to the situation at hand, as most have potential resources such as land, livestock, and crops that could be converted into money (Russell, 1996; Wallman and Baker, 1996). In other words, they make discretional choices between selling assets and borrowing money.
In the health sectors of low- and middle-income countries, contingent valuation method (CVM) studies on willingness to pay (WTP) have been used to gather information on demand variation or financial perspectives alongside price setting, such as the introduction of user fees and valuation of quality improvements. However, WTP found in most CVM studies have only explored the preferences that consumers express through their WTP without exploring whether they are actually able to pay for it. Therefore, this study examines the issues pertaining to WTP estimation for health services using the conventional CVM.
We conducted 202 household interviews in 2008, in which we asked respondents about three types of public health services in Indonesia and assessed WTP estimated by the conventional CVM as well as in the scenario of “resorting to debt” to recognize their budget constraints.
We find that all the demand curves for both WTP scenarios show gaps. Furthermore, the gap for midwife services is negatively affected by household income and is larger for the poor. These results prove that CVM studies on WTP do not always reveal WTP in the latter scenario. Those findings suggest that WTP elicited by the conventional CVM is different to that from the maximum price that prevents respondents from resorting to debt as their WTP. In order to bridge this gap in the body of knowledge on this topic, studies should improve the scenarios that CVM analyses use to explore WTP. Furthermore, because valuing or pricing health services based on the results of CVM studies on WTP alone can exacerbate the inequity of access to these services, information provided by such studies requires careful interpretation when used for this purpose, especially for the poor and vulnerable sections of society.
Are health services protecting the livelihoods of the urban poor in Sri Lanka? Findings from two low-income areas of Colombo
2006, Social Science and Medicine
Investing in pro-poor health services is central to poverty reduction and achievement of the Millennium Development Goals. As health care financing mechanisms have an important influence over access and treatment costs they are central to the debates over health systems and their impact on poverty. This paper examines people's utilisation of health care services and illness cost burdens in a setting of free public provision, Sri Lanka. It assesses whether and how free health care protected poor and vulnerable households from illness costs and illness-induced impoverishment, using data from a cross-sectional survey (423 households) and longitudinal case study household research (16 households). The findings inform policy debates about how to improve protection levels, including the contribution of free health care services to poverty reduction. Assessment of policy options that can improve health system performance must start from a better understanding of the demand-side influences over performance.
Traditional herbal drugs of Southern Uganda, II: Literature analysis and antimicrobial assays
2003, Journal of Ethnopharmacology
Continuing field interviews brought the total species used for disease treatment by herbalists of the majority Baganda Tribe of southern Uganda to 168. Literature searches provided support for the ethnomedical claims for a number of these species, and provided criteria for the species classification into four categories of use validation. They also helped guide the selection of species for recollection, for chemical extraction and further testing in laboratories of the Uganda Ministry of Health and the University of Illinois at Chicago. Many species proved active against microorganisms in several susceptibility assays conducted in Uganda and the US.
Economic role of solidarity and social capital in accessing modern health care services in the Ivory Coast
2002, Social Science and Medicine
At the beginning of the 1990s, health service reforms were implemented in public health institutions in most African countries South of the Sahara. In the Ivory Coast, the imposition of user fees for public services was adopted in 1994. Such fees require each person to have adequate financial resources in order to access modern health care services. Many poor people—despite their poverty—are able to access modern health care services that have become quite expensive. The factor that allows this access lies within the solidarity of parents, friends or members of a social network. In Africa, illness is a social phenomenon and a state of illness is negative. The sick human being is one who cannot fully participate in community life. The treatment of a sick person is, then, an act, which is tied to the systems of life, which are produced and maintained collectively. Once the causes of illness are identified and consequences evaluated, it is the entire family or group that participates in the finances which bring about treatment. In this study, we show the role of social capital in the processes of financial solidarity for access to modern health care services that now require payment. Our investigation provides valuable insights on the role of social capital with respect to social strategies and community financing mechanisms for the acquisition of modern health care in Africa.
Ordinary women and shapes of knowledge: Perspectives on the context of STD and AIDS
1998, Public Understanding of Science

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

General paperWhich resources pay for treatment? A model for estimating the informal economy of health

Abstract

Soc. Sci. Med.

Kampala Women Getting By: Wellbeing in the Time of AIDS

Sex and death: the AIDS crisis in social and cultural context

J. AIDS

The Myth of the Hidden Economy

Social Innovation and the Division of Labour

Treatment Sources Survey