Abstract
Purpose
The use of traction for treatment of femoral shaft fractures remains common in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The objective of this study is to systematically review the literature on outcomes of traction as definitive treatment for adult femoral shaft fractures in LMICs.
Methods
Using the recommended PRISMA methods for systematic reviews, MEDLINE, EMBASE, LILACS, and AJOL were searched for relevant publications. Results were limited to studies occurring in LMICs as defined by the World Bank. Data on time spent in traction (TT), length of stay (LOS), time to partial weight bearing (PWB), complication incidences, and a total complication incidence were recorded.
Results
Of the 693 initial results, nine were eligible for analysis giving a total of 455 unique patients with a mean age of 32.9 years (range: 0 to 96). The average time spent in traction was 52.8 days (range: 19.8 to 122.5), the average length of stay was 55.4 days (range: 45 to 140), and the average time to partial weight bearing was 52.2 days (range: 42 to 60 days). There were a total of 91 malunions, 25 un-united fractures, 60 infections, 45 other complications, giving a total of 221 complications in 455 patients.
Conclusions
The use of traction in treating femoral shaft fractures is associated with a high incidence of complications and prolonged course of treatment. Although operative stabilization may be a better alternative, comparative studies are needed to assess whether this can be achieved in a safe and cost-effective manner for widespread application in LMICs.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Lim SS, Vos T, Flaxman AD et al (2012) A comparative risk assessment of burden of disease and injury attributable to 67 risk factors and risk factor clusters in 21 regions, 1990-2010: a systematic analysis for the global burden of disease study 2010. Lancet 9859:2224–2260. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(12)61766-8
Phillips J, Jergesen HE, Caldwell A et al (2009) IGOT-the institute for global orthopaedics and traumatology: a model for collaboration and change. Tech Orthop 4:308–311. doi:10.1097/BTO.0b013e3181c3ebb1
Bach O (2004) Musculoskeletal trauma in an East African public hospital. Injury 4:401–406. doi:10.1016/S0020-1383(03)00290-0
Mathers C, Fat DM, Boerma JT (2008) The global burden of disease: 2004 update. World Health Organization, Geneva
Bong MR, Koval KJ, Egol KA (2006) The history of intramedullary nailing. Bull NYU Hosp Jt Dis 3–4:94–97
Vecsei V, Hajdu S, Negrin LL (2011) Intramedullary nailing in fracture treatment: history, science and Kuntscher's revolutionary influence in Vienna, Austria. Injury 42:S1–S5. doi:10.1016/S0020-1383(11)00419-0
Moher D, Liberati A, Tezlaff J et al (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Ann Intern Med 4:264–269
The World Bank (2014) Country classifications. Online
Iotov A, Takov E, Ivanov V et al (1996) Infraisthmal femoral fractures: cast bracing or interlocking intramedullary nailing? Ortopediya i Travmatologiya 2:58
Ikem IC, Oginni LM, Bamgboye EA (2001) Open fractures of the lower limb in Nigeria. Int Orthop 6:386–388
Mandrella B (2002) The conservative treatment of femur fractures by Perkins traction. Management in adverse situations. Unfallchirurg 10:923–931. doi:10.1007/s00113-002-0467-7
Gosselin R, Lavaly D (2007) Perkins traction for adult femoral shaft fractures: a report on 53 patients in Sierra Leone. Int Orthop 5:697–702. doi:10.1007/s00264-006-0233-5
Gosselin RA, Heitto M, Zirkle L (2009) Cost-effectiveness of replacing skeletal traction by interlocked intramedullary nailing for femoral shaft fractures in a provincial trauma hospital in Cambodia. Int Orthop 5:1445–1448. doi:10.1007/s00264-009-0798-x
Clasper JC, Rowley DI (2009) Outcome, following significant delays in initial surgery, of ballistic femoral fractures managed without internal or external fixation. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 1:97–101. doi:10.1302/0301-620x.91b1.21106
Doorgakant A, Mkandawire NC (2012) The management of isolated closed femoral shaft fractures in a district hospital in Malawi. Trop Dr 1:8–12. doi:10.1258/td.2011.110211
Bezabeh B, Wamisho BL, Coles MJ (2012) Treatment of adult femoral shaft fractures using the Perkins traction at Addis Ababa Tikur Anbessa University Hospital: the Ethiopian experience. Int Surg 1:78–85. doi:10.9738/cc48.1
Opondo E, Wanzala P, Makokha A, (2013) Cost effectiveness of using surgery versus skeletal traction in management of femoral shaft fractures at Thika level 5 hospital, Kenya. Pan Afr Med J 42 doi: 10.11604/pamj.2013.15.42.2451
Buxton RA (1981) The use of Perkins' traction in the treatment of femoral shaft fractures. J Bone Joint Surg (Br) 3:362–366
Soren OO (2010) Outcome of surgical implant generation network nail initiative in treatment of long bone shaft fractures in Kenya. East Afr Orthop J 1:7–14. doi:10.4314/eaoj.v3i1.62557
Fakhry SM, Rutledge R, Dahners LE et al (1994) Incidence, management, and outcome of femoral shaft fracture: a statewide population-based analysis of 2805 adult patients in a rural state. J Trauma 2:255–260, discussion 260-251
Sekimpi P, Okike K, Zirkle L et al (2011) Femoral fracture fixation in developing countries: an evaluation of the Surgical Implant Generation Network (SIGN) intramedullary nail. J Bone Joint Surg Am 19:1811–1818. doi:10.2106/JBJS.J.01322
Fadero PE, Alabi S, Adebule GT et al (2008) Locked intramedullary nailing for the treatment of femoral shaft fractures: experience and result in 19 cases. Niger J Med 2:168–172
The World Bank (2012) GNI per capita. Online
Navidi WC (2008) Statistics for engineers and scientists, McGraw-Hill, New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Grant support
No grant support to report.
Conflict of interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
Appendix A Search terminology and equations
Appendix A Search terminology and equations
MEDLINE (4/23/2014)
“Traction AND (femoral fractures[Mesh] OR femur[tiab] OR femoral[tiab] OR leg bone*[tiab] OR long bone*[tiab]) AND (Afghanistan[Mesh] OR Bangladesh[Mesh] OR Benin[Mesh] OR Burkina Faso[Mesh] OR Burundi[Mesh] OR Cambodia[Mesh] OR Central African Republic[Mesh] OR Chad[Mesh] OR Comoros[Mesh] OR Democratic Republic of the Congo[Mesh] OR Eritrea[Mesh] OR Ethiopia[Mesh] OR Gambia[Mesh] OR Guinea[Mesh] OR Guinea-Bissau[Mesh] OR Haiti[Mesh] OR Kenya[Mesh] OR Democratic People's Republic of Korea[Mesh] OR Kyrgyzstan[Mesh] OR Liberia[Mesh] OR Madagascar[Mesh] OR Malawi[Mesh] OR Mali[Mesh] OR Mozambique[Mesh] OR Myanmar[Mesh] OR Nepal[Mesh] OR Niger[Mesh] OR Rwanda[Mesh] OR Sierra Leone[Mesh] OR Somalia[Mesh] OR Sudan[Mesh] OR Tajikistan[Mesh] OR Tanzania[Mesh] OR Togo[Mesh] OR Uganda[Mesh] OR Zimbabwe[Mesh] OR Armenia[Mesh] OR Bhutan[Mesh] OR Bolivia[Mesh] OR Cameroon[Mesh] OR Cape Verde[Mesh] OR Congo[Mesh] OR Cote d'Ivoire[Mesh] OR Djibouti[Mesh] OR Egypt[Mesh] OR El Salvador[Mesh] OR "Georgia (Republic)"[Mesh] OR Ghana[Mesh] OR Guatemala[Mesh] OR Guyana[Mesh] OR Honduras[Mesh] OR Indonesia[Mesh] OR India[Mesh] OR Kosovo[Mesh] OR Laos[Mesh] OR Lesotho[Mesh] OR Mauritania[Mesh] OR Moldova[Mesh] OR Mongolia[Mesh] OR Morocco[Mesh] OR Nicaragua[Mesh] OR Nigeria[Mesh] OR Pakistan[Mesh] OR Papua New Guinea[Mesh] OR Paraguay[Mesh] OR Philippines[Mesh] OR Samoa[Mesh:noexp] OR Independent State of Samoa[Mesh] OR Senegal[Mesh] OR Sri Lanka[Mesh] OR Sudan[Mesh] OR Swaziland[Mesh] OR Syria[Mesh] OR East Timor[Mesh] OR Ukraine[Mesh] OR Uzbekistan[Mesh] OR Vanuatu[Mesh] OR Vietnam[Mesh] OR Yemen[Mesh] OR Zambia[Mesh] OR Afghani*[tiab] OR Bangladesh*[tiab] OR Benin[tiab] OR "Burkina Faso"[tiab] OR Burundi*[tiab] OR Cambodia*[tiab] OR "Central African Republic"[tiab] OR Chad[tiab] OR Comoros[tiab] OR Congo*[tiab] OR Zaire[tiab] OR Eritrea*[tiab] OR Ethiopia*[tiab] OR Gambia*[tiab] OR Guinea*[tiab] OR "Guinea-Bissau"[tiab] OR Haiti*[tiab] OR Kenya*[tiab] OR "Democratic People's Republic of Korea"[tiab] OR "North Korea"[tiab] OR North Korean*[tiab] OR Kyrgyz*[tiab] OR Liberia*[tiab] OR Madagascar[tiab] OR Malawi[tiab] OR Malawian*[tiab] OR Mali[tiab] OR Mozambique[tiab] OR Myanmar[tiab] OR Burma[tiab] OR Burmese[tiab] OR Nepal[tiab] OR Nepalese[tiab] OR Niger[tiab] OR Rwanda*[tiab] OR "Sierra Leone"[tiab] OR Somalia[tiab] OR Somali[tiab] OR Somalis[tiab] OR "South Sudan"[tiab] OR Tajikistan*[tiab] OR Tadjikistan*[tiab] OR Tanzania*[tiab] OR Zanzibar*[tiab] OR Tanganyika[tiab] OR Togo[tiab] OR Togolese[tiab] OR Uganda*[tiab] OR Zimbabw*[tiab] OR Rhodesia*[tiab] OR Armenia*[tiab] OR Bhutan*[tiab] OR Bolivia*[tiab] OR Cameroon*[tiab] OR "Cape Verde"[tiab] OR "Cote d'Ivoire"[tiab] OR "Ivory Coast"[tiab] OR Djibouti*[tiab] OR Egypt*[tiab] OR El Salvador*[tiab] OR "Georgia Republic"[tiab] OR "Republic of Georgia"[tiab] OR Ghana*[tiab] OR Guatemal*[tiab] OR Guyana[tiab] OR Guyanese[tiab] OR "British Guiana"[tiab] OR Hondur*[tiab] OR India[tiab] OR "Asian Indian"[tiab] OR "Asian Indians"[tiab] OR Indonesia*[tiab] OR Kiribati[tiab] OR Kosovo[tiab] OR Kosovan*[tiab] OR Kosovar*[tiab] OR Laos[tiab] OR "Lao PDR"[tiab] OR "LAO People's Democratic Republic"[tiab] OR Lao people*[tiab] OR Laotian*[tiab] OR Lesotho*[tiab] OR Mauritania*[tiab] OR (Micronesia*[tiab] AND "Federated States"[tiab]) OR Moldova*[tiab] OR Mongolia*[tiab] OR Morocc*[tiab] OR Nicaragua*[tiab] OR Nigeria*[tiab] OR Pakistan*[tiab] OR "Papua New Guinea"[tiab] OR Paraguay[tiab] OR Paraguayan*[tiab] OR Philippines[tiab] OR Filipino*[tiab] OR Filipina*[tiab] OR Samoa*[tiab] OR "Sao Tome"[tiab] OR Senegal[tiab] OR Senegalese[tiab] OR Solomon Island*[tiab] OR "Sri Lanka"[tiab] OR Sri Lankan*[tiab] OR Ceylon[tiab] OR Sudan*[tiab] OR Swaziland[tiab] OR Syria*[tiab] OR "Timor-Leste"[tiab] OR "East Timor"[tiab] OR Ukrain*[tiab] OR Uzbekistan*[tiab] OR Vanuatu*[tiab] OR Vietnam*[tiab] OR "West Bank"[tiab] OR Gaza[tiab] OR Palestin*[tiab] OR Yemen*[tiab] OR Zambia*[tiab] OR Afghanistan[ad] OR Bangladesh[ad] OR Benin[ad] OR “Burkina Faso”[ad] OR Burundi[ad] OR Cambodia[ad] OR “Central African Republic”[ad] OR Chad[ad] OR Comoros[ad] OR Congo[ad] OR Zaire[ad] OR Eritrea[ad] OR Ethiopia[ad] OR Gambia[ad] OR Guinea[ad] OR “Guinea-Bissau”[ad] OR Haiti[ad] OR Kenya[ad] OR “Democratic People's Republic of Korea”[ad] OR “North Korea”[ad] OR Kyrgyz* [ad] OR Liberia[ad] OR Madagascar[ad] OR Malawi[ad] OR Mali[ad] OR Mozambique[ad] OR Myanmar[ad] OR Burma[ad] OR Nepal[ad] OR Niger[ad] OR Rwanda[ad] OR “Sierra Leone”[ad] OR Somalia[ad] OR “South Sudan”[ad] OR Tajikistan[ad] OR Tadjikistan OR Tanzania[ad] OR Zanzibar[ad] OR Tanganyika[ad] OR Togo[ad] OR Uganda[ad] OR Zimbabwe[ad] OR Rhodesia[ad] OR Armenia[ad] OR Bhutan[ad] OR Bolivia[ad] OR Cameroon[ad] OR “Cape Verde”[ad] OR “Cote d'Ivoire”[ad] OR “Ivory Coast”[ad] OR Djibouti[ad] OR Egypt[ad] OR “El Salvador”[ad] OR “Georgia Republic”[ad] OR “Republic of Georgia”[ad] OR Ghana[ad] OR Guatemala[ad] OR Guyana[ad] OR Honduras[ad] OR India[ad] OR Indonesia[ad] OR Kiribati[ad] OR Kosovo[ad] OR Laos[ad] OR “Lao PDR” OR LAO People*[ad] OR Lesotho[ad] OR Mauritania[ad] OR “Federated States of Micronesia”[ad] OR Moldova[ad] OR Mongolia[ad] OR Morocco[ad] OR Nicaragua[ad] OR Nigeria[ad] OR Pakistan[ad] OR “Papua New Guinea”[ad] OR Paraguay[ad] OR Philippines[ad] OR Samoa[ad] OR “Sao Tome”[ad] OR Senegal[ad] OR “Solomon Islands”[ad] OR “Sri Lanka”[ad] OR Ceylon[ad] OR Sudan[ad] OR Swaziland[ad] OR Syria[ad] OR “Syrian Arab Republic”[ad] OR “Timor-Leste”[ad] OR “East Timor”[ad] OR Ukraine[ad] OR Uzbekistan[ad] OR Vanuatu[ad] OR Vietnam[ad] OR “West Bank”[ad] OR Gaza[ad] OR Palestine[ad] OR Yemen[ad] OR Zambia[ad] OR Angola[Mesh] OR Albania[Mesh] OR Algeria[Mesh] OR Argentina[Mesh] OR Azerbaijan[Mesh] OR Belarus[Mesh] OR Belize[Mesh] OR “Bosnia and Herzegovina”[Mesh] OR Botswana[Mesh] OR Brazil[Mesh] OR Bulgaria[Mesh] OR China[Mesh] OR Colombia[Mesh] OR “Costa Rica”[Mesh] OR Cuba[Mesh] OR Dominica[Mesh] OR “Dominican Republic”[Mesh] OR Ecuador[Mesh] OR Fiji[Mesh] OR Gabon[Mesh] OR Grenada[Mesh] OR Hungary[Mesh] OR Iran[Mesh] OR Iraq[Mesh] OR Jamaica[Mesh] OR Jordan[Mesh] OR Kazakhstan[Mesh] OR Lebanon[Mesh] OR Libya[Mesh] OR Macedonia[Mesh] OR Malaysia[Mesh] OR Maldives[Mesh] OR “Marshall Islands”[Mesh] OR Mauritius[Mesh] OR Mexico[Mesh] OR Montenegro[Mesh] OR Namibia[Mesh] OR Palau[Mesh] OR Panama[Mesh] OR Peru[Mesh] OR Romania[Mesh] OR Serbia[Mesh] OR Seychelles[Mesh] OR South Africa[Mesh] OR St. Lucia[Mesh] OR “St. Vincent and the Grenadines”[Mesh] OR Suriname[Mesh] OR Thailand[Mesh] OR Tonga[Mesh] OR Tunisia[Mesh] OR Turkey[Mesh] OR Turkmenistan[Mesh] OR Tuvalu[Mesh] OR Venezuela OR Angola*[Tiab] OR Albania*[Tiab] OR Algeria*[Tiab] OR Argentin*[Tiab] OR Azerbai*[Tiab] OR Belarus*[Tiab] OR Beli*[Tiab] OR “Bosnia and Herzegovina”[Tiab] OR Botswan*[Tiab] OR Brazil*[Tiab] OR Bulgaria*[Tiab] OR China[Tiab] OR Chinese[Tiab] OR Colombia*[Tiab] OR “Costa Rica”[Tiab] OR “Costa Rican”[Tiab] OR Cuba*[Tiab] OR Dominica*[Tiab] OR “Dominican Republic”[Tiab] OR Ecuador*[Tiab] OR Fiji*[Tiab] OR Gabon*[Tiab] OR Grenada*[Tiab] OR Hungary[Tiab] OR Hungarian[Tiab] OR Iran*[Tiab] OR Iraq*[Tiab] OR Jamaica*[Tiab] OR Jordan*[Tiab] OR Kazakhstan*[Tiab] OR Lebanon[Tiab] OR Lebanese[Tiab] OR Libya*[Tiab] OR Macedonia*[Tiab] OR Malaysia*[Tiab] OR Maldives[Tiab] OR Maldivian[Tiab] OR “Marshall Islands”[Tiab] OR Mauritius[Tiab] OR Mexico[Tiab] OR Mexican[Tiab] OR Montenegro[Tiab] OR Namibia*[Tiab] OR Palau*[Tiab] OR Panama*[Tiab] OR Peru*[Tiab] OR Romania*[Tiab] OR Serbia*[Tiab] OR Seychelles[Tiab] OR South Africa*[Tiab] OR St. Lucia*[Tiab] OR “St. Vincent and the Grenadines”[Tiab] OR Surinam*[Tiab] OR Thailand [Tiab] OR Thai[Tiab] OR Tonga*[Tiab] OR Tunisia*[Tiab] OR Turkey[Tiab] OR Turkish[Tiab] OR Turkmenistan*[Tiab] OR Tuvalu*[Tiab] OR Venezuela* OR Angola[Ad] OR Albania[Ad] OR Algeria[Ad] OR Argentina[Ad] OR Azerbaijan[Ad] OR Belarus[Ad] OR Belize[Ad] OR “Bosnia and Herzegovina”[Ad] OR Botswana[Ad] OR Brazil[Ad] OR Bulgaria[Ad] OR China[Ad] OR Colombia[Ad] OR “Costa Rica”[Ad] OR Cuba[Ad] OR Dominica[Ad] OR “Dominican Republic”[Ad] OR Ecuador[Ad] OR Fiji[Ad] OR Gabon[Ad] OR Grenada[Ad] OR Hungary[Ad] OR Iran[Ad] OR Iraq[Ad] OR Jamaica[Ad] OR Jordan[Ad] OR Kazakhstan[Ad] OR Lebanon[Ad] OR Libya[Ad] OR Macedonia[Ad] OR Malaysia[Ad] OR Maldives[Ad] OR “Marshall Islands”[Ad] OR Mauritius[Ad] OR Mexico[Ad] OR Montenegro[Ad] OR Namibia[Ad] OR Palau[Ad] OR Panama[Ad] OR Peru[Ad] OR Romania[Ad] OR Serbia[Ad] OR Seychelles[Ad] OR South Africa[Ad] OR St. Lucia[Ad] OR “St. Vincent and the Grenadines”[Ad] OR Suriname[Ad] OR Thailand[Ad] OR Tonga[Ad] OR Tunisia[Ad] OR Turkey[Ad] OR Turkmenistan[Ad] OR Tuvalu[Ad] OR Venezuela OR developing countries[Mesh] OR "developing country"[tiab] OR "developing countries"[tiab] OR LMIC[tiab] OR LMICs[tiab] OR "low income countries"[tiab] OR "low income country"[tiab] OR "low and middle income countries"[tiab] OR "low and middle income country"[tiab] OR "lower middle income countries"[tiab] OR "lower middle income country"[tiab] OR "developing nation"[tiab] OR "developing nations"[tiab] OR "developing world"[tiab] OR "developing economy"[tiab] OR "developing economies"[tiab] OR "transitional country"[tiab] OR "transitional countries"[tiab] OR "global burden"[tiab] OR "global health"[tiab] OR global orthop*[tiab] OR "global outreach"[tiab] OR "global public health"[tiab] OR (global[ti] AND watch[ti]) OR global[ti] OR "international health"[tiab] OR "international public health"[tiab] OR world health[majr] OR international cooperation[majr] OR "resource poor"[tiab] OR austere environment*[tiab] OR “limited resource”[tiab] OR “limited resources”[tiab] OR "third world"[tiab] OR Africa[Mesh] OR Africa*[tiab] OR sahara*[tiab] OR subsahara*[tiab] OR Asia[Mesh] OR asia*[tiab] OR Central America[Mesh] OR central America*[tiab] OR Europe, Eastern[Mesh] OR eastern Europe*[tiab] OR South America[Mesh] OR South America*[tiab] OR Caribbean Region[Mesh] OR Caribbean[tiab] OR Middle East[Mesh:noexp] OR USSR[Mesh] OR ussr[tiab] OR ussr[ad] OR u.s.s.r.[tiab] OR u.s.s.r.[ad] OR “Union of Soviet Socialist Republics”[tiab] OR “Union of Soviet Socialist Republics”[ad] OR “Soviet Union”[tiab] OR “Soviet Union”[ad] OR Soviet*[tiab] OR Russia*[tiab] OR Russia*[ad] OR Yugoslavia[Mesh] OR Yugoslav*[tiab] OR Yugoslav*[ad]) NOT (animals[Mesh] NOT humans[Mesh]”
EMBASE (4/25/2014)
“traction AND ('femur fracture'/exp OR femur:ab,ti OR femoral:ab,ti OR 'leg bone':ab,ti OR 'leg bones':ab,ti OR 'long bone':ab,ti OR 'long bones':ab,ti OR 'leg fracture'/mj) AND ('afghanistan'/de OR 'bangladesh'/de OR 'benin'/de OR 'burkina faso'/de OR 'burundi'/de OR 'cambodia'/de OR 'central african republic'/de OR 'chad'/de OR 'comoros'/de OR 'democratic republic congo'/de OR 'eritrea'/de OR 'ethiopia'/de OR 'gambia'/de OR 'guinea'/de OR 'guinea-bissau'/de OR 'haiti'/de OR 'kenya'/de OR 'north korea'/de OR 'kyrgyzstan'/de OR 'liberia'/de OR 'madagascar'/de OR 'malawi'/de OR 'mali'/de OR 'mozambique'/de OR 'myanmar'/de OR 'nepal'/de OR 'niger'/de OR 'rwanda'/de OR 'sierra leone'/de OR 'somalia'/de OR 'tajikistan'/de OR 'tanzania'/de OR 'togo'/de OR 'uganda'/de OR 'zimbabwe'/de OR 'armenia'/de OR 'bhutan'/de OR 'bolivia'/de OR 'cameroon'/de OR 'cape verde'/de OR 'congo'/de OR 'cote d`ivoire'/exp OR 'djibouti'/de OR 'egypt'/de OR 'el salvador'/de OR 'georgia (republic)'/de OR 'ghana'/de OR 'guatemala'/de OR 'guyana'/de OR 'honduras'/de OR 'indonesia'/de OR 'india'/de OR 'kosovo'/de OR 'laos'/de OR 'lesotho'/de OR 'mauritania'/de OR 'federated states of micronesia'/de OR 'moldova'/de OR 'mongolia'/de OR 'morocco'/de OR 'nicaragua'/de OR 'nigeria'/de OR 'pakistan'/de OR 'papua new guinea'/de OR 'paraguay'/de OR 'philippines'/de OR 'samoa'/de OR 'sao tome and principe'/de OR 'senegal'/de OR 'solomon islands'/de OR 'sri lanka'/de OR 'sudan'/de OR 'swaziland'/de OR 'syrian arab republic'/de OR 'timor-leste'/de OR 'ukraine'/de OR 'uzbekistan'/de OR 'vanuatu'/de OR 'vietnam'/de OR 'palestine'/de OR 'yemen'/de OR 'zambia'/de OR afghani*:ab,ti OR bangladesh*:ab,ti OR benin:ab,ti OR 'burkina faso':ab,ti OR burundi*:ab,ti OR cambodia*:ab,ti OR 'central african republic':ab,ti OR chad:ab,ti OR comoros:ab,ti OR congo:ab,ti OR congolese:ab,ti OR zaire:ab,ti OR eritrea*:ab,ti OR ethiopia*:ab,ti OR gambia*:ab,ti OR guinea*:ab,ti OR 'guinea-bissau':ab,ti OR haiti*:ab,ti OR kenya*:ab,ti OR 'north korea':ab,ti OR 'north korean':ab,ti OR 'north koreans':ab,ti OR kyrgyz*:ab,ti OR liberia*:ab,ti OR madagascar:ab,ti OR malawi:ab,ti OR mali:ab,ti OR mozambique:ab,ti OR myanmar:ab,ti OR burma:ab,ti OR burmese:ab,ti OR nepal:ab,ti OR nepalese:ab,ti OR niger:ab,ti OR rwanda*:ab,ti OR 'sierra leone':ab,ti OR somalia:ab,ti OR somali:ab,ti OR somalis:ab,ti OR 'south sudan':ab,ti OR tajikistan*:ab,ti OR tadjikistan*:ab,ti OR tanzania*:ab,ti OR zanzibar*:ab,ti OR tanganyika:ab,ti OR togo:ab,ti OR togolese:ab,ti OR uganda*:ab,ti OR zimbabw*:ab,ti OR rhodesia*:ab,ti OR armenia*:ab,ti OR bhutan*:ab,ti OR bolivia*:ab,ti OR cameroon*:ab,ti OR 'cape verde':ab,ti OR ivoire:ab,ti OR 'ivory coast':ab,ti OR djibouti*:ab,ti OR egypt*:ab,ti OR 'el salvador':ab,ti OR 'el salvadoran':ab,ti OR 'el salvadorans':ab,ti OR 'georgia republic':ab,ti OR 'republic of georgia':ab,ti OR ghana*:ab,ti OR guatemal*:ab,ti OR guyana:ab,ti OR guyanese:ab,ti OR 'british guiana':ab,ti OR hondur*:ab,ti OR india:ab,ti OR 'asian indian':ab,ti OR 'asian indians':ab,ti OR indonesia*:ab,ti OR kiribati:ab,ti OR kosovo:ab,ti OR laos:ab,ti OR 'lao pdr':ab,ti OR laotian*:ab,ti OR 'lao people':ab,ti OR 'lao peoples':ab,ti OR lesotho*:ab,ti OR mauritania*:ab,ti OR (micronesia:ab,ti AND 'federated states') OR moldova:ab,ti OR mongolia*:ab,ti OR morocc*:ab,ti OR nicaragua*:ab,ti OR nigeria*:ab,ti OR pakistan*:ab,ti OR 'papua new guinea':ab,ti OR paraguay:ab,ti OR philippines:ab,ti OR filipino*:ab,ti OR filipina*:ab,ti OR samoa*:ab,ti OR 'sao tome':ab,ti OR senegal:ab,ti OR senegalese:ab,ti OR 'solomon island':ab,ti OR 'solomon islands':ab,ti OR 'sri lanka':ab,ti OR 'sri lankan':ab,ti OR 'sri lankans':ab,ti OR ceylon:ab,ti OR sudan*:ab,ti OR swaziland:ab,ti OR syria*:ab,ti OR 'timor-leste':ab,ti OR 'east timor':ab,ti OR ukrain*:ab,ti OR uzbekistan*:ab,ti OR vanuatu*:ab,ti OR vietnam*:ab,ti OR 'west bank':ab,ti OR gaza:ab,ti OR palestin*:ab,ti OR yemen*:ab,ti OR zambia*:ab,ti OR afghanistan:ad OR bangladesh:ad OR benin:ad OR 'burkina faso':ad OR burundi:ad OR cambodia:ad OR 'central african republic':ad OR chad:ad OR comoros:ad OR congo:ad OR zaire:ad OR eritrea:ad OR ethiopia:ad OR gambia:ad OR guinea:ad OR 'guinea-bissau':ad OR haiti:ad OR kenya:ad OR (democratic:ad AND 'republic of korea':ad) OR 'north korea':ad OR kyrgyz*:ad OR liberia:ad OR madagascar:ad OR malawi:ad OR mali:ad OR mozambique:ad OR myanmar:ad OR burma:ad OR nepal:ad OR niger:ad OR rwanda:ad OR 'sierra leone':ad OR somalia:ad OR 'south sudan':ad OR tajikistan:ad OR tadjikistan OR tanzania:ad OR zanzibar:ad OR tanganyika:ad OR togo:ad OR uganda:ad OR zimbabwe:ad OR rhodesia:ad OR armenia:ad OR bhutan:ad OR bolivia:ad OR cameroon:ad OR 'cape verde':ad OR ivoire:ad OR 'ivory coast':ad OR djibouti:ad OR egypt:ad OR 'el salvador':ad OR 'georgia republic':ad OR 'republic of georgia':ad OR ghana:ad OR guatemala:ad OR guyana:ad OR honduras:ad OR india:ad OR indonesia:ad OR kiribati:ad OR kosovo:ad OR laos:ad OR 'lao pdr':ad OR 'lao people':ad OR lesotho:ad OR mauritania:ad OR 'federated states of micronesia':ad OR moldova:ad OR mongolia:ad OR morocco:ad OR nicaragua:ad OR nigeria:ad OR pakistan:ad OR 'papua new guinea':ad OR paraguay:ad OR philippines:ad OR samoa:ad OR 'sao tome':ad OR senegal:ad OR 'solomon islands':ad OR 'sri lanka':ad OR ceylon:ad OR sudan:ad OR swaziland:ad OR syria:ad OR 'syrian arab republic':ad OR 'timor-leste':ad OR 'east timor':ad OR ukraine:ad OR uzbekistan:ad OR vanuatu:ad OR vietnam:ad OR 'west bank':ad OR gaza:ad OR palestine:ad OR yemen:ad OR zambia:ad OR 'developing country'/de OR 'developing country':ab,ti OR 'developing countries':ab,ti OR lmic:ab,ti OR lmics:ab,ti OR 'low income countries':ab,ti OR 'low income country':ab,ti OR 'low and middle income countries':ab,ti OR 'low and middle income country':ab,ti OR 'lower middle income countries':ab,ti OR 'lower middle income country':ab,ti OR 'developing nation':ab,ti OR 'developing nations':ab,ti OR 'developing world':ab,ti OR 'developing economy':ab,ti OR 'developing economies':ab,ti OR 'transitional country':ab,ti OR 'transitional countries':ab,ti OR 'global burden':ab,ti OR 'global health':ab,ti OR 'global orthopedic':ab,ti OR 'global orthopedics':ab,ti OR 'global orthopaedic':ab,ti OR 'global orthopaedics':ab,ti OR 'global orthopedist':ab,ti OR 'global orthopedists':ab,ti OR 'global orthopaedist':ab,ti OR 'global orthopaedists':ab,ti OR 'global outreach':ab,ti OR 'global public health':ab,ti OR 'global watch':ab,ti OR global:ti OR 'international health':ab,ti OR 'international public health':ab,ti OR 'international cooperation'/mj OR 'resource poor':ab,ti OR 'austere environment':ab,ti OR 'limited resource':ab,ti OR 'limited resources':ab,ti OR 'third world':ab,ti OR 'africa'/exp OR africa*:ab,ti OR sahara*:ab,ti OR subsahara*:ab,ti OR 'asia'/exp OR asia*:ab,ti OR 'south and central america'/exp OR 'central america':ab,ti OR 'central americas':ab,ti OR 'central american':ab,ti OR 'central americans':ab,ti OR 'south america':ab,ti OR 'south americas':ab,ti OR 'south american':ab,ti OR 'south americans':ab,ti OR 'eastern europe'/exp OR 'eastern europe':ab,ti OR 'eastern european':ab,ti OR 'eastern europeans':ab,ti OR 'caribbean islands'/exp OR caribbean:ab,ti OR 'middle east'/de OR 'ussr'/exp OR ussr:ab,ti OR ussr:ad OR 'u s s r':ab,ti OR 'u s s r':ad OR 'union of soviet socialist republics':ab,ti OR 'union of soviet socialist republics':ad OR 'soviet union':ab,ti OR 'soviet union':ad OR soviet*:ab,ti OR russia*:ab,ti OR russia*:ad OR 'yugoslavia (pre-1992)'/exp OR yugoslav*:ab,ti OR yugoslav*:ad) NOT ([animals]/lim NOT ([humans]/lim OR 'patient'/exp))”
LILACS (4/3/2014)
1. “femur” AND “traction;” 2. “femoral” AND “traction.”
AJOL (4/3/2014)
“femur” OR “femoral” AND “traction.”
Eq. 1
“\( {\displaystyle \sum_{\mathrm{i}=1}^{\mathrm{k}}}{n}_i{m}_i \div {\displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^{\mathrm{k}}}{n}_i \)” where “n” is the number of patients in a study, “m” is the reported mean for the given variable, and “k” is the number of studies used.
Eq. 2
“\( \left({\displaystyle \sum_{\mathrm{i}=1}^{\mathrm{k}}}{n}_i{\widehat{p}}_i \div {\displaystyle \sum_{i=1}^k}{\widehat{p}}_i\right)\div \) (\( \left[{\displaystyle \sum_{\mathrm{i}=1}^{\mathrm{k}}}{n}_i\right]\div k \))” where “\( \widehat{p} \)” is the proportion of patients suffering specified complication events.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kramer, E.J., Shearer, D. & Morshed, S. The use of traction for treating femoral shaft fractures in low- and middle-income countries: a systematic review. International Orthopaedics (SICOT) 40, 875–883 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-015-3081-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-015-3081-3