Table 2

Interventions, effect size estimates and costs by condition

InterventionBase valueMin. valueMax. valueAverage monthly cost per adolescent (2019 US$)
LICLMICUMICHIC
Prevention interventions
Universal prevention of anxiety and depressionSchool-based prevention delivered by teachers( 21 ) $0.01$0.08$0.37$7.31
Relative risk of developing internalising disorder (both anxiety and depression), postintervention( 80 ) 0.390.260.59
Relative risk of developing internalising disorder (both anxiety and depression), 1–3 months( 80 ) 0.350.240.53
Relative risk of developing internalising disorder (both anxiety and depression), 6–9 months( 80 ) 0.490.370.64
Relative risk of developing depression, postintervention( 80 ) 0.410.240.69
Relative risk of developing depression, 1–3 months( 80 ) 0.350.240.53
Relative risk of developing depression, 6–9 months( 80 ) 0.460.350.62
Relative risk of developing anxiety, postintervention( 80 ) 0.250.100.65
Indicated prevention of depressionScreening and in person group-based CBT delivered in schools( 21 ) <$0.01$0.01$0.04$0.79
Relative risk of developing depression, postintervention( 21 ) 0.320.140.73
Relative risk of developing depression, 6 months( 21 ) 0.340.200.59
Relative risk of developing depression, 1 year( 21 ) 0.710.351.43
Relative risk of developing depression, 2 years( 21 ) 0.740.411.36
Prevention of suicideUniversal school-based prevention( 81 ) <$0.01
$0.01$0.01$0.69
OR for incident suicide attempts at 3 months( 81 ) 0.780.421.44
OR for incident suicide attempts at 12 months( 81 ) 0.450.240.85
Targeted prevention in hospitals among adolescents who have self-harmed( 26 ) $0.05$0.08$0.14$6.52
Risk ratio of probability of suicide among people who have self-harmed after receiving targeted follow-up( 26 ) 0.110.020.45
Treatment interventions
Treatment of anxietyIn-person group CBT( 23 ) $0.04
$0.12$0.27$15.60
OR for remission of anxiety, postintervention( 23 ) 7.863.8316.12
Summary OR for remission of anxiety, 2 years( 23 ) 3.220.9610.75
Individual CBT delivered via internet platform$2.19$2.39$3.91$157.64
OR for remission of anxiety, postintervention( 23 ) 7.863.8316.12
Summary OR for remission of anxiety, 2 years( 23 ) 3.220.9610.75
Internet-based guided self-help( 24 ) $0.53
$0.90$1.58$70.97
OR for remission of anxiety, post-treatment( 24 ) 5.412.2612.90
Treatment of mild and moderate depressionIn-person group CBT( 82 ) $0.04$0.12$0.27$15.60
Relative risk of depression, post-treatment( 82 ) 0.230.130.40
Relative risk of depression, 4–9 months( 82 ) 0.370.150.92
Individual CBT delivered via internet platform$2.19$2.39$3.91$157.64
Relative risk of depression, post-treatment( 82 ) 0.230.130.40
Relative risk of depression, 4–9 months( 82 ) 0.370.150.92
Internet-based guided self-help$0.53$0.90$1.58$70.97
Relative risk of depression, post-treatment( 82 ) 0.230.130.40
Relative risk of depression, 4–9 months( 82 ) 0.370.150.92
Treatment of severe depressionIn-person individual CBT and medication( 83 ) $1.61$3.95$8.03$444.54
OR for remission of severe depression, post-treatment( 84 ) 3.001.585.79
Treatment of bipolar disorderFamily-focused treatment and medication( 37 ) $4.14$5.12$7.91$182.88
HR for recovery from depressive symptoms, 2 years( 37 ) 1.851.043.29
  • Costs represent monthly costs per adolescent given in 2019 US$ for every year after the first. Costs are slightly higher in the first year to reflect start-up costs, primarily initial trainings. For more information on the differences between relative risks, ORs and HRs, please see online supplemental file 1.

  • CBT, cognitive behavioural therapy; HIC, high-income country; HR, hazard ratio; LIC, low-income country; LMIC, lower-middle income country; OR, odds ratio; UMIC, upper-middle income country.