Table 2

Linear regression output for excess mortality per 100 000 individuals evaluated at 100 days, 300 days, 400 days and 500 days following the first confirmed case of COVID-19 within a country

Excess mortality per 100 000 individuals at 100 daysExcess mortality per 100 000 individuals at 300 daysExcess mortality per 100 000 individuals at 400 days after adjusting for vaccinationExcess mortality per 100 000 individuals at 500 days after adjusting for vaccination
Explanatory variableCoefficientRobust SEP valueStd. βCoefficientRobust SEP valueStd. βCoefficientRobust SEP valueStd. βCoefficientRobust SEP valueStd. β
Sociodemographic
Island status−50.967−11.7220.000−0.281−49.17211.6210.000−0.271−76.39822.1610.001−0.277−120.64124.5260.000−0.341
Share of pop. >65 years335.504−120.1890.0060.342339.927121.5480.0060.347447.300209.3830.0350.306518.959278.9950.0660.268
Governance and politics
Corruption Perceptions Index−1.909−0.5170.000−0.536−1.7950.5050.001−0.504−2.9460.9800.003−0.547−3.7351.1520.002−0.528
Social cohesion−0.709−0.1610.000−0.349−0.7280.1520.000−0.358−0.7690.2990.012−0.248−1.4790.4420.001−0.370
(6.1) Political and security risk1.088−0.3140.0010.3570.9650.3130.0030.3161.3530.6360.0360.2752.0780.7650.0080.322
Political polarisation*−6.928−4.4950.126−0.142−7.1414.2320.094−0.146−8.6247.3780.246−0.118−10.5948.2710.203−0.108
Public health capacity
(2.4) Data integration between human, animal and environmental health sectors0.175−0.1080.1090.1250.1690.1070.1150.1220.1240.1660.4580.0600.4060.2300.0810.148
(1.6) Immunisation0.383−0.3970.3370.0660.2610.4010.5170.0450.5350.8410.5260.0541.7921.0100.0790.160
(4.3) Healthcare access−0.281−0.3350.404−0.058−0.2610.3390.443−0.0540.0150.5210.9760.002−0.5710.6760.401−0.055
Response
(3.7) Trade and travel restrictions0.77−0.2720.0060.1540.7250.2590.0060.1451.0950.4310.0130.1390.9120.6030.1340.091
Previous experience with SARS or MERS−24.241−10.3870.021−0.167−24.90110.5420.020−0.172−29.25020.1680.150−0.134−14.21324.2540.559−0.050
(3.2) Exercising response plans0.32−0.1430.0280.1440.3090.1410.0300.1400.3640.2440.1400.1110.2950.3060.3370.068
Stringency of interventions at day X0.219−0.2310.3460.0600.5230.2690.0550.1260.0550.5570.9220.0090.5720.5670.3150.074
Other
(6.4) Environmental risks−1.529−0.5510.007−0.227−1.4740.5430.008−0.218−2.1471.0250.039−0.209−4.9581.1080.000−0.374
Polarisation of society*−10.66−4.5420.021−0.217−9.8404.6270.036−0.200−14.3608.2140.084−0.192−11.49111.4210.317−0.117
(5.3) International commitments0.345−0.1870.0670.1670.2960.1870.1150.1430.4360.3380.2010.1410.8230.4530.0720.199
(5.4) JEE and PVS−0.345−0.2370.148−0.106−0.2960.2350.211−0.091−0.3990.4240.349−0.082−0.1700.5360.752−0.028
(5.6) Commitment to sharing of genetic and biological data and specimens−0.65−0.6110.290−0.0880.5570.5840.343−0.075−0.3720.9220.687−0.036−0.7621.0860.484−0.054
(5.1) IHR reporting compliance and disaster risk reduction0.193−0.1960.326−0.1420.1900.1940.3280.0660.3160.3480.3670.073−0.0640.4680.892−0.011
(2.3) Epidemiology workforce−0.14−0.1810.439−0.060−0.1150.1840.533−0.049−0.3960.3180.216−0.107−0.5610.3800.143−0.117
Fully vaccinated people per 100 individuals−0.3780.9730.699−0.0230.1430.7990.8580.019
Constant102.8865.8940.12198.57265.8710.137147.662109.2370.180271.6561142.26740.059
Mean variance inflation factor1.8501.8601.8001.900
Observations128128112117
R-squared0.5880.5970.5340.566
Indicates statistical significance to p<0.05 level.
Indicates statistical significance to p<0.1 level.
  • The standardised beta compares the strength of the effect of each individual independent variable to the dependent variable. A negative beta value (represented in green) indicates fewer excess deaths and therefore a better response. A positive beta value (represented in orange) suggests that the variable had a detrimental effect on the quality of the response, correlating with a greater number of deaths. Yellow shading represents a result that is statistically significant to the p<0.05 level. Blue shading represents a result that is statistically significant to the p<0.10 level.

  • *Variables measuring political and societal polarisation were scored in a manner where a lower score indicates significant polarisation, and an increase in score represents a decrease in polarisation.

  • JEE, Joint External Evaluation; MERS, Middle East respiratory syndrome; PVS, Performance of Veterinary Services; SARS, Severe acute respiratory syndrome.