Table 1

Survey items*† used to measure violent discipline of children

SurveyOriginal survey items (translated into English if needed)Physical (verbal) acts measured‡
Bolivia
2008
Who punishes your sons (daughters) in the household? Anyone else? father; mother; stepfather; stepmother; grandfather; grandmother; older sister; household worker; other; no one (not punished)pull ears or slap/smack
beat on the body
(Verbal: Shout, insult)
if father: How does your husband/partner punish your sons/ daughters? if mother: How do you punish your sons/daughters? if other: How does that person punish your sons/daughters?
Colombia
2015
Who punishes your sons (daughters) (or your step or adopted sons (daughters)) in the household? Anyone else? father/stepfather; mother/respondent/ stepmother; other; no one (not punished)slap/smack
push
beat with objects
if father/stepfather: How does your partner punish your (step, adopted) sons (daughters)? if respondent: How do you punish your (step, adopted) sons (daughters)? if other: How does that person punish your (step, adopted) sons (daughters)?
Guatemala
2008/2009
Who punishes your sons/daughters in the household? father; mother; other; no one (not punished)spank
beat or ‘physical punishment’
burn
make kneel on corn or rocks
if father: How does the father punish your sons/daughters? if mother: How do you/the mother punish your sons/daughters? if other: How does that person punish your sons/daughters?
Haiti 2016/2017In the past month, did you or anyone else in your household:
…shake (name)? … yell or shout at (name)? …pull (name’s) ears? …make (name) kneel? …spank or hit (name) on the bottom with a bare hand? …hit (name) on the bottom or elsewhere on the body with something like a belt, whip, stick or other hard object? …call (name) an idiot, lazy, ugly or something like that? …slap or punch (name) on the face, head or ears? …hit (name) on the hand, arm or leg? …beat (name), that is to say… hit over and over as hard as possible?
Shake
Pull ears
Make kneel
Spank/hit on bottom with bare hand
Hit with belt, whip, stick, or other hard object
Slap or punch on face, head, ears
Hit on hand, arm, leg
Beat (hit over and over as hard as possible)
(Verbal: Yell or shout; Call names)
Jamaica
2008/2009
In this household, are the children punished when they do not behave well? yes; no; no children (age 1–15) in the householdcuff or spank
hit with hand or fist
hit with belt, stick, other object
if yes: How are the children punished when they don't behave well? Another way?
Mexico 2016When your husband or partner becomes angry or desperate with his/your daughters and sons, does he hit them…
When you become angry or desperate with your daughters and sons, do you hit them…
…. sometimes? frequently? does not hit them? no sons/daughters?
Hit
Nicaragua 2011/2012In this household, how are children disciplined when they behave badly?smack/slap
hit with hand or fist
beat with belt, ruler, whip/rope, stick, other object
Paraguay 2008In your household, how are children punished? Anything else?same as nicaragua
Peru
2018
Who reprimands or punishes your daughters or sons in the household? Anyone else? biological father; biological mother; other; no one (not punished)slap/smack
beat or ‘physical punishment’
if biological father: How does your husband/partner punish your daughter(s) or son(s)? if biological mother: How do you punish your daughter(s) or son(s)? if other: How does that person punish your daughter(s) or son(s)?
  • *Spanish and French survey items were translated into English by authors.

  • †Words in small caps font were coded but not read to respondent.

  • ‡All surveys except Mexico also measured acts of non-violent discipline, which are not shown.