Table 1

Summary of study designs, quantitative measures, analysis type and associations between exposure and outcome in quantitative studies (N=20) and mixed-methods study (N=1)

Study designNo of studiesReference
Quasi-experimental21 37–43 46–59
Longitudinal2 40 41
Cross-sectional19 37–39 42 43 46–59
No comparison groups3 53–55
Comparison groups16 37–39 42 43 46–52 56 58 59
Measures of exposure and outcome variables No of studies* Reference
Exposure variable
Ecological
(eg, spatial data on residency and severity of disaster)
6 40–43 55 57
Self-reported disaster experience
Binary variable of affectedness
(eg, Were you affected by disaster?)
1 39
Ordered categorical variable of affectedness2 37 38
Proxy measures (eg, living in displacement camp)6 46 47 49 50 54 58
Not specified or unclear6 48 51–53 56 59
Outcome variable
Validated scale4 37 49 58 59
Experience of a range of violent acts8 39 42 43 46–48 56 58 59
Experience of violence (general)9 38 40 47 50–55
Other2 41 57
Analysis type No of studies Reference
Unadjusted or unclear9 39 49 52–57 59
Adjusted or multivariate12 37 38 40–43 46–48 50 51 58
Association between disaster exposure and VAWG No of studies Reference
Exposure associated with increased VAWG8 37 38 41–43 46 57 59
Exposure associated with decreased VAWG0
Exposure associated with no effect on VAWG5 39 49–52
Exposure associated with mixed effects on VAWG4 40 47 48 58
Cannot determine relationship4 53–56
  • *The number of studies does not equal 21 because some studies used multiple measures of exposure and/or outcome variables.

  • VAWG, violence against women and girls.