Table 1

Characteristics of included articles

StudyArticle aimCVDCountry (income level)SettingSampleMethodologyFramework details
Barello et al27Identify features and the levers of patient with HF engagementHFItaly (HIC)University Hospital in Milan22 participants (13 patients, 5 physicians, 4 caregivers)Qualitative, SSI Grounded theory.Inductive, ‘Process of engagement in patients with HF’.
Bokhour et al28Explore patients’ ‘explanatory models’ and context, relate to self-managementHTUSA (HIC)Medical centres48 African-American, white and Latino patients/veteransQualitative, SSI Grounded theoryInductive, ‘The dynamic model of HT self-management behaviour’.
Byrne et al18Describe illness perceptions and beliefs about medication of patientsCHDIreland (HIC)General practice outpatients1084 patients under the age of 80Quantitative, cross-sectional, postal questionnairesDeductive, SRM modified to include treatment and medication beliefs.
Chen et al19Test relationship between illness perception to self-managementHTTaiwan (HIC)CVD clinics of teaching hospitals355 patientsQuantitative, cross-sectional, structured questionnairesInductive/deductive: ‘Model for adherence to therapeutic regimens’, modified CSM.
Dickson et al 31Examine contribution of attitudes, self-efficacy and cognition to managementHFUSA (HIC)Outpatients of medical centre41 patientsMixed, qualitative SSI, quantitative cross-sectional surveyDeductive, modified Decision-making model of HF management.
Fort et al 29Present patients’ perceptions of barriers and facilitators to managementHT and DBCosta Rica/Mexico (UMIC)Urban public health centres70 patientsQualitative, focus group discussions Thematic analysisDeductive, TM.
Horowitz et al30Elucidate patients' knowledge and beliefs, understand self-care routinesCHFUSA (HIC)Urban tertiary care hospital19 former inpatientsQualitative, SSI, Grounded theoryInductive/deductive: models of CHF and CSM.
Kressin et al 20Explore links between race, beliefs about HT and adherence.HTUSA (HIC)Veteran's affairs hospital793 outpatients (460 African-American, 333 white)Quantitative, cross-sectional structured questionnairesDeductive, adapted HDM combined with several other scales.
Luder et al 21Describe features and beliefs of enrolees of employer-based DB and HT programmeHT and DBUSA (HIC)Pharmacies154 enrolees of employer-led DB and HT coaching programmeQuantitative, cross-sectional using surveyDeductive, HBM, TPB and TRA.
Peleg et al 22Assess role of attitudes, norms and behavioural control on adherenceACSIsrael (HIC)Cardiac care units in urban hospitals106 married/cohabitating male patientsQuantitative, longitudinal surveysDeductive, TPB and Attachment Theory.
Platt et al 23Examine adherence to medication, exercise and dietCHDAustralia (HIC)Outpatient clinics142 outpatientsQuantitative, cross-sectional using questionnaireDeductive, CSM, TM and positive and negative affect.
Presseau et al 32Compare approaches for identifying determinants of adherence post-MIMICanada (HIC)Hospitals24 outpatients for qualitative, 201 for quantitativeMixed, qualitative SSI, quantitative: structured surveysDeductive, TDF and HAPA.
Quine et al 24Propose and test a model of adherence to antihypertensive medicationHTUK (HIC)Primary care934 outpatients at 1 of 3 practicesQuantitative, prospective longitudinal using two surveysInductive, a conceptual model of adherence to HT medication.
Sniehotta et al 25Test, compare, combine CSM and extended TPBCHDUK (HIC)Hospitals, patient homes103 outpatients in phase III cardiac rehabilitationQuantitative, prospective cohort designDeductive, CSM and TPB.
Vellone et al 26Test situation-specific theory of HF self-care with modellingHFItaly (HIC)Outpatient settings417 outpatients aged 18 years and olderQuantitative, secondary analysis of data from cross-sectional studyDeductive, situation-specific theory of HF.
  • ACS, acute coronary syndrome; BP, blood pressure; CHD, coronary heart disease; CHF, congestive heart failure; CSM, common-sense self-regulation model; DB, diabetes; HAPA, health action process approach; HBM, health belief model; HDM, health decision model; HF, heart failure; HIC, high-income economy; HT, hypertension; LMIC, low-income to middle-income economy; MI, myocardial infarction; SRM, self-regulatory model; SSI, semi-structured interview; TDF, theoretical domains framework; TM, transtheoretical model; TPB, theory of planned behaviour; TRA, theory of reasoned action; UMIC, upper-income to middle-income economy.