Table 4

Proposed enablers and barriers

Community contextDescriptionDiscussed by
Pre-existing povertyMaterial poverty, poor access to employment and education, financial dependence on husbands or employers, insecure tenure of housing.30 37 43 45 49 50 54 55 58 67 76 83 84 110 112 127
Supportive institutional-political contextPolitical will to tackle health issue, health system minimally functioning and able to respond to community concerns, lack of violent conflict, insecurity and instability.25 59–61 71 73 74 76 78 80 111 118 127
Pre-existing social cohesionExisting sense of belonging, identity and trust, existing social networks and community groups, history of living and working together.22 30 50 64 70 73 83 84 121 127
Supportive pre-existing health beliefs, attitudes and normsExisting awareness and concern with health issue, prior confidence that issue can be addressed, culture of open discussion around issue.37 50 54 59 61 69 83 111 127
Pre-existing power hierarchies in the communityLack of voice and decision-making power for women in the community, stigmas of sex and reproduction, power relations between men.22 42 50 53 54 58 59 63 64 68 69 81 83 118 127
Pre-existing power hierarchies within householdsGeneral lack of female household agency; husbands forbidding wives to attend group meetings; unequal power relations between daughters-in-law and mothers-in-law.42 43 49 50 58 59 62 67 69 79 81 82 110 114 119
Intervention contextDescriptionDiscussed by
Intervention design and management
Staff managementEffective recruitment, training and supervision of group facilitators; staff confidence, motivation and retention.37 42 49 52 58 67 78 80 83 107 112 125
Incentives for participationCash or food transfers at group meetings; reimbursements for taxi fare; microfinance initiatives; help accessing entitlements.37 43 48 55 58 59 70 86 87 107 108
Managing community relationsEngaging stakeholders; avoiding backlash; building relationships with community members.2 50 52 61 78 83 87 122
Intervention implementation
Respect for local people, knowledge and practicesAvoiding trying to ‘teach’ group members and being open to learning from group members; negotiating flexibly, not demanding change.37 42 48–50 61 62 69 114 122 127
Relevant education toolsLocally accessible education materials; relevant language used; presence of a meeting agenda.42 48–50 69 107 109
Inclusion of less powerful subpopulationsParticipation of less powerful community members and equal opportunity for all to contribute to group activities37 48 50–52 69 83 107 109 114 122