Table 1

Characteristics of studies included in the qualitative synthesis

StudyYearCountryStudy designDiagnosisStudy perspectiveInputs included in cost analysis*Cost outcomes (in 2018 USD)CHEERS
checklist (out of 24)
Multiple childhood cancers
Bhakta et al172013Brazil and MalawiCA, CEA, CUAALL and BLN/AN/ACost-effectiveness thresholds (using 3% discounting):
ALL in Brazil:
Upper limit of cost effective: $560 106 per case
Upper limit of very cost effective: $186 701 per case
BL in Malawi:
Upper limit of cost effective: $30 273 per case
Upper limit of very cost effective: $10 091 per case
21
Fuentes-Alabi et al182018El SalvadorCA, CEA, CUAAll childhood cancersHospitalComprehensiveAnnual cost to maintain paediatric cancer treatment programme: $5 440 465
Cost per newly diagnosed patient per year: $30 035
Cost per DALY averted using 3% discounting: $1699
23
Jasso-Gutierrez et al412012MexicoCAALL and HLNot specifiedLowCost of cancer drugs (remission induction stage and consolidation):
ALL:
Standard-risk ALL: $4982 for 20 kg child and $6663 for 30 kg child
High-risk and very high-risk ALL: $5575 for 20 kg child and $7456 for 30 kg child
HL:
Stages IA and IIA: $222 for 20 kg child and $277 for 30 kg child.
Stages IB and IIB: $2735 for 20 kg child and $3659 for 30 kg child.
Stages III and IV: $2883 for 20 kg child and $3857 for 30 kg child
16
Neal et al492018RwandaCAWT and HLHospitalComprehensiveWT: cost per treated patient per year: $1913 ($1362–$1913)
HL: cost per treated patient per year: $1638 ($1042–$1638)
22.5
Renner et al162018GhanaCA, CEA, CUAAll childhood cancersHospitalComprehensiveAnnual cost to operate a paediatric cancer unit: $1 791 797.
Cost per newly diagnosed patient per year: $10 540
Cost per life saved: $30 115
Cost per DALY averted using 3% discounting: $1114
22
Leukaemias
Jaime-Perez et al402017MexicoCAALLPublic health system, hospital and patientMediumCost per treated patient: $20 954 to $24 788.20
Gao et al312013ChinaCAALLPatientLowCost per treated patient:
ALL-BFM 2002: median $14 124 ($8003–$50 002)
ALL China-98: median $27 209 ($17 156–$79 334)
16
Garcia et al322015ColombiaCA, CEAAMLHeath systemLowCost per treated patient:
Chemotherapy only: $14 731
Unrelated transplant: $65 486
Related transplant: $85 114
ICER for related transplant compared with chemotherapy: $2744
ICER for unrelated transplant compared with chemotherapy: $3868
23
Ghatak et al332016IndiaCAALLPatientComprehensiveDuring first month of therapy (induction phase):
Cost of medical expenditure per patient: $574 (IQR $433–$851).
Total cost of nonmedical expenditure per patient: $227 (IQR $156–$322).
19
Gu et al342008ChinaCAALLPatientLowCost per treated patient was $26 800 for low-risk, $35 734 for medium-risk and $44 667 for high-risk patients, respectively.13.5
Hayati et al352018IranCUAALLNot specifiedMediumCost per treated patient:
UK-ALL protocol: $9323
BFM-ALL protocol: $16 914
Cost per QALY gained:
UK-ALL protocol: $2104
BFM-ALL protocol: $4475
18
Islam et al382015BangladeshCAALLPatientComprehensiveCost per treated patient: $5684 ($4182–$9814)21
Jayaraman et al422017IndiaCAALLNot specifiedLowCost of each vial of Peg-asparaginase was $2309
Each vial of 3750 units/mL was shared among 3–4 children.
14.5
Liu et al452009ChinaCAALLHospitalMediumCosts per treated patient: $17 295±10 914 ($8782–78 218)18.5
Luo et al462008ChinaCAALLPatientMediumChina-98 protocol:
Cost per treated patient (median and range): $18 791 ($13 064–$38 487)
Modified ALLIC BFM200 protocol:
Cost per treated patient (median and range): $14 953 ($10 370–$29 142)
Economic protocol:
Cost per treated patient (median and range): $6391 ($4683–$10 250)
19
Luo et al472009ChinaCAAPLNot specifiedLowCost per treated patient:
In-house protocol: median $24 704 ($16 305–$34 092)
Modified PETHEMA protocol: median $5806 ($3335–$10 623)
11.5
Rocha-Garcia et al512003MexicoCAALLPatientMediumCost per treated child: $71918
Wilms tumour
Israels et al392018Malawi, Cameroon and GhanaCAWTPatientLowCost per treated patient: $105–$1151.15.5
Kanyamuhunga et al442015RwandaCAWTHospital and patientMediumCost per treated patient: $1796 for early stage and $2372 for advanced disease stage19.5
Paintsil et al502015Ethiopia, Ghana, Cameroon, Malawi and UgandaCAWTPatientMediumCost per treated patient:
Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (Ghana): $1110
Korle Bu Teaching Hospital (Ghana): $1110
Uganda Cancer Institute (Uganda): $211
Queen Elizabeth Central Hospital (Malawi): $122
Mbingo, Mutengene and Banso Baptist Hospitals (Cameroon): $416
Tikur Anbessa Specialised Hospital (Ethiopia): $388
17
Burkitt lymphoma
Denburg et al302019UgandaCA, CEA, CUABLGovernmentComprehensiveCost per treated child US$1401
Annual national cost of treatment: $864 854
Cost per DALY averted using 3% discounting $100
23.5
Hesseling et al372003MalawiCABLNot specifiedLowCost per treated patient: <$21712.5
Meremikwu et al482005NigeriaCABLPatientMediumCost for a 7 years old child with BL (including 6-course treatment regimen): $14116.5
Traoré et al532011Burkina-Faso, Cameroon, Ivory Coast, Madagascar, Mali, and SenegalCABLNot specifiedLowCost per treated child: $79912.5
Hodgkin lymphoma
Stefan and Stones522009South AfricaCAHLNot specifiedLowHL stage II: cost per treated child $736018.5
Retinoblastoma
Ji et al432012ChinaCARetinoblastomaPatientComprehensiveCost per treated patient: $9954±$3919
Medical costs: $7250±$3659
Non-medical costs: $2705±$1424
20
Waddell et al542015UgandaCARetinoblastomaNot specifiedLowCost per treated child: $1079.12.5
Yao et al552018DRC and Ivory CoastCARetinoblastomaNot specifiedLowCost per treated child:
Lubumbashi (DRC): $1475
Kinshasa (DRC): $879
Bukavu (DRC): $637
Abidjan (Ivory Coast): $527
10.5
Other
Agarwal et al292007IndiaCAOsteosarcomaPatientLowCost of rotationplasty: $661 including cost of prosthesis
Cost of indigenous non-expandable prosthesis: $1321
Cost of expandable prosthesis: $33 029
13.5
Hendricks et al362011South AfricaCAExtracranial germ cell tumoursNot specifiedLowCost per treated patient by treatment regimen: Cisplatin (×3 cycles) $2470. Carboplatin (×4 cycles $529, (×5 cycles) $662, (×6 cycles) $79416
  • *Comprehensive: ≥10 inputs, Medium: 5–9 inputs, Low: <5 inputs.

  • ALL, acute lymphoblastic leukaemia; AML, acute myeloid leukaemia; APL, acute promyelocytic leukaemia; BL, Burkitt lymphoma; CA, cost analysis; CEA, cost-effectiveness analysis; CUA, cost-utility analysis; DALY, disability-adjusted life year; DRC, Democratic Republic of Congo; HL, Hodgkin lymphoma; ICER, incremental cost-effectiveness ratio; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; WT, Wilms tumour.