Table 1

Data sources by article and SP study

Authors
(Date)
Short titleSettingSectorHealth service(s) AassessedLevel: sample size*Data source descriptions
Daniels et al (2017)Use of SPs to assess quality of healthcare in Nairobi, KenyaUrban KenyaPublic and privateAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, tuberculosis (TB), unstable anginaFacility: 166Nairobi SP data
Multiple CountriesPublic and privateAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, TB, unstable anginaFacility: 2255SP data for international comparisons
Das et al (2015)21Use of SPs to assess quality of TB careUrban IndiaPrivateTB (four cases)Provider: 250Validation study for four TB cases
Urban IndiaPrivateTB (one case)Provider: 69Know-do gap for textbook TB case
Das et al (2016 Science)15The impact of training informal healthcare providers in IndiaRural IndiaPrivateAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, TB, unstable anginaProvider: 860SP data
Das et al (2016 AER)12Quality and Accountability in Healthcare DeliveryRural IndiaPrivateAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, TB, unstable anginaProvider: 1109SP data
Rural IndiaPrivate and PublicAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, TB, unstable anginaProvider: 455Same providers at public and private locations
Kwan et al (2018)22 and Daniels et al (2019)14Variations in the quality of TB care in urban India and use of SPs to assess gender differences in quality of TBUrban IndiaPrivateTB (four cases)Facility and provider: 2602Interactions for four cases weighted for representative levels of quality across two cities
Urban IndiaPrivateTB (one case and variant)Provider: 101Interactions for one case to assess effect of diagnostic report
Satyanarayana et al (2016)23Use of SPs to assess antibiotic dispensing for TB by pharmacies in urban IndiaUrban IndiaPrivateTBPharmacist: 1200Interactions for two cases weighted for representative levels of quality across three cities
Urban IndiaPrivateTB (two cases)Pharmacist: 2593Medicines for interactions across three cities
Sylvia et al (2015)29Survey using incognito SPs shows poor quality care in China’s rural clinicsRural ChinaPublic and privateAsthma, childhood diarrhoea, unstable anginaLev: 82SP data
Rural ChinaPublic and privateTBProvider: 274SP data
Sylvia et al (2017)27TB detection and the challenges of integrated care in rural ChinaRural ChinaPublic and privateTB (one case)Provider: 486Know-do gap for textbook TB case
Unpublished (n.d.)Qutub Project, 2014 to presentUrban IndiaPrivateTB (four cases and variants)Round 1: N=1636 interactions (n=999 with AYUSH, n=637 with allopathic facilities and providers); Round 2: N=2231 interactionsQuality of care surveillance conducted with stratified, random samples of providers
  • *Number of interactions available for analysis at facility and/or provider level in replication data.

  • SP, standardised patient.