Table 1

List of the included studies: systematic reviews

Author and titleInterventionOutcomes
Systematic reviews
Alvarez et al, 201531
  •  Health system model

  •  Community engagement

  •  Intersectoral collaboration

Decentralisation, access to healthcare, quality of care
Baygi et al, 201337
  •  Health system model

Decentralisation of workforce as part of health systems reform
Bosch‐Capblanch et al, 200841
  •  Workforce supervision

Availability of workforce, quality of care
Bosch‐Capblanch et al, 201142
  •  Workforce supervision

Service coverage
Hone et al, 201746
  •  User fee

Service coverage, compliance
Kiwanuka et al, 201118
  •  Workforce management

Compliance, availability of workforce
Kruk et al, 201038
  •  Health system model

Service coverage, integration, access to healthcare, compliance, quality of care
Kok et al, 201519
  •  Workforce management

Accountability, quality of care
Larye et al, 201520
  •  Health system model

  •  Workforce management

Health system reform, access to healthcare, availability of workforce
Laurant et al, 200521
  •  Workforce management

Compliance, quality of care
Lewin et al, 200522
  •  Workforce management

Service coverage, compliance, availability of workforce
Lewin et al, 201023
  •  Workforce management

  •  Education and training

Service coverage, compliance
Li et al, 201724
  •  Workforce management

  •  Infrastructure

Service coverage, availability of workforce
Liu et al, 200747
  •  Contracting out

Service coverage, access to healthcare, quality of care
Lodenstein et al, 201632
  •  Community engagement

Accountability, access to healthcare, quality of care
Martínez-González et al, 201425
  •  Workforce management

Service coverage, compliance, quality of care
Nora et al, 201326
  •  Workforce management

  •  Infrastructure

  •  Referral

  •  User–provider communication

Access to healthcare, compliance, availability of workforce, quality of care
Nunan and Duke, 201133
  •  Education and training

  •  Community engagement

  •  Workforce supervision

  •  User-fee

  •  Public–private partnership

Service coverage
Paula et al, 201639
  •  Health system model

Service coverage, access to healthcare, quality of care
Ramírez et al, 201127
  •  Workforce management

  •  Community engagement

  •  Infrastructure

  •  Intersectoral collaboration

Service coverage, Health system reform, access to healthcare
Schveitzer et al, 201628
  •  Workforce management

  •  Education and training

Availability of workforce, quality of care,
Tabrizi et al, 201740
  •  Health system model

Health system reform, access to healthcare
Vasan et al, 201743
  •  Workforce supervision

  •  Education and training

Service coverage, quality of care
Willcox et al, 201529
  •  Workforce management

  •  Education and training

Availability of workforce
Impact evaluation studiesStudy designInterventionOutcomes
Heard et al, 2013, Bangladesh48 Baseline follow-up surveyContracting outService coverage, access to healthcare, quality of care
Santos et al, 2017, Brazil30 Quasi-experimental, before-and-after studyWorkforce managementAvailability of workforce, service coverage, access to healthcare
Sudhipongpracha, 2013, Thailand34 Comparative case studyHealth system modelDecentralisation of workforce
Community engagementQuality of care, social responsibilities
Hotchkiss et al, 2005, Albania35 Baseline follow-up surveyEducation and TrainingQuality of care
InfrastructureQuality of care
Community engagementService coverage, access to healthcare
Alhassan et al, 2015, Ghana36 RCTCommunity engagementQuality of care
Frimpong et al, 2011, Philippines44 Time use studyWorkforce supervisionQuality of care, service coverage
Loevinsohn et al, 199545 Controlled before-and-after designWorkforce supervisionService coverage, quality of care
  • RCT, randomised controlled trial.