Table 1

Why, what and how we measure health systems drivers of women’s, children’s and adolescents’ health with a governance focus

Why we measureWhat we measureHow we measure
FramingHealth systems drivers relevant to governanceMeasurement variablesResearch epistemologies, methodologies and methodsResearch continuum
Lens: Service delivery
Focus: Health conditions with effective interventions
View of power:
 Technocratic
Mode of governance:
 Hierarchical
Implementation focus:
 Blueprints for what works
  •  Policy mandate

  •  Coordination for continuity across levels and sectors

  •  Service delivery readiness

  •  User characteristics

  •  Technical content of policies

  •  Management mechanisms: committees, review meetings, etc

  •  Inputs/resources (human resources for health, supplies, finances)

  •  User profile (literacy, gender, class, ethnicity, age)

Epistemology:
 Positivist
Methods:
  •  Measuring adherence to recommended protocols (users and providers)

  •  Applying implementation checklists

  •  Analysing household, facility surveys or routine HMIS and system-generated data

  •  Ecological analysis of large datasets

Disciplines:
Epidemiology, demography
Approach:
Replicable measurements that validate progress or highlight gaps
Evidence:
Cross-national data sets
Embedded Image




Disciplines:
Multiple social science disciplines
Approach:
Context embedded research
Reflective practice
Evidence:
Tacit and experiential knowledge
Lens: Societal
Focus: People with rights
View of power:
  1.  Unidirectional/power over/zero-sum

  2.  Co-produced/relational


Mode of governance:
 Negotiating interests, enabling collaboration
Implementation focus:
 Social processes/relationships
Macro: Political prioritisation
Meso: Accountability dynamics
Micro: Interpersonal dynamics supporting empowerment or marginalisation
  •  Stakeholder positions and interests

  •  Participation/mobilisation

  •  Organisational cultures

  •  Transparency

  •  Credibility/trust

  •  Social capital and networks

  •  Social/informal norms

  •  Framing

Epistemology:
 Legal
 Pragmatic/constructivist
Methodologies:
  •  Legal analysis

  •  Health policy and systems research


Methods:
  •  Stakeholder analysis, political mapping

  •  Social network analysis

  •  Case study research

Lens: Systems
Focus: Complexity
View of power:
  •  Creative: disruptive/productive


Mode of governance:
 Principles enabling emergence
Implementation focus:
 Interventions and people interact and evolve overtime
  •  Dis/equilibria

  •  Feedback loops

  •  Eventuality of change

  •  Emergence

  •  Path dependence

  •  Diversity of actors, varying power, alignment and interests

  •  Contextual permeability

  •  Adaptive or learning capacities

  •  Tipping points and motivation for emergence and change

Epistemology:
 Constructivist
Methodologies:
  •  Ethnography

  •  Participatory action research

  •  Systems modelling


Methods:
  •  Hidden transcripts

  •  Causal loop diagrams

  • HMIS, health management and information systems.