Table 5

Synthesis of results according to parenting exposure: poor-medium quality studies (score ≤4) (n=26)

Parenting roleSexual and reproductive healthMental healthEducational achievementAdaptive functioningConduct disorderSubstance useTotal
Connection1 4↑51 55 57 53*1↓81
3↑78 80 82
4↑69–71 74 2↑63 68 1↓81
13↑51 53* 55 57 63 68–71 74 78 80 82
Connection2 general communication
Connection3 sexual and reproductive health communication4↑55–58
1↓51
1↔60
4↑55–58
1↓51
1↔60
Positive behaviour control1 (monitoring)4↑56–58 60 1↑79 2↑69 70 1↑63 1↑49 1↑90 10↑49 56–58 60 63 69 70 79 90
Negative behaviour control2 (harsh)1↓79 1↓73 1↓68 2↓84 86 5↓68 73 79 84 86
Role modelling (of positive or negative behaviour)1↑70(positive modelling for education)1↓90(negative modelling of substance use)1↑(positive modelling)70
1↓(negative modelling)90
Provision and protection 1↑69 1↑63 2↑63 69
Parenting style: authoritarian1↑57 1↓812↓64 67 1↑57
3↓64 67 81
Parenting style: authoritative1↑57 3↑64 65 67 4↑57 64 65 67
Total studies75553126
  • Positive outcome↑, negative outcome↓, inconsistent↔.

  • *For girls only.

  • †Indicates paternal warmth.

  • ‡Indicates maternal.