Introducing malaria rapid diagnostic tests at registered drug shops in Uganda: Limitations of diagnostic testing in the reality of diagnosis
Highlights
► This study analyses the potential for malaria rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) to be introduced into registered drug shops.► The social context of drugs shops can be defined by their liminal status, a position that conflicts with adherence to clinical guidelines.► Malaria is defined by individually known symptoms and treatments rather than by the presence of parasites in the blood.► Clients’ curiosity about RDTs, to confirm known diagnoses, waned in the face of costs and conflict between results and symptoms.► Interventions should see drug shops as partners and raise awareness of multiple causes and management of malaria-like illness.
Introduction
The treatment of febrile illnesses in malaria-endemic countries has received increasing attention in the past decade, with huge efforts to scale up the use of Artemesinin Combination Therapies (ACTs) for malaria cases. The high cost of these treatments, together with recognition of the importance of non-malarial fevers, has prompted reconsideration of existing strategies of blanket antimalarial use for fever cases in favour of restricted antimalarial prescription based on evidence of malaria parasitaemia (D’Acremont et al., 2009). The World Health Organisation policy guidelines have recently changed to recommend parasitologically confirmed antimalarial treatment where possible (World Health Organisation, 2010).
Accurate microscopy testing for malaria is only available in limited locations due to its dependence upon skilled laboratory staff and technical equipment. The accuracy of results is compromised if either staff skills or equipment are lacking (Ibrahim, 1996, Ngasala et al., 2008). For parasitological diagnosis to be taken up in low-resource settings, tests that can be carried out without extensive skills or equipment are needed. The new generation of malaria rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) fulfils these criteria, offering accurate diagnosis (Bell et al., 2001) in a relatively simple format that requires no electricity or specialized laboratory training (D’Acremont et al., 2009). RDTs are therefore seen as an important vehicle for achieving targeted malaria treatment.
To make the greatest impact on current use of antimalarials, testing needs to be available where patients currently seek treatment. RDTs are now being introduced at many government health facilities in malaria-endemic countries. However, policy makers recognise the limited reach of such activities, given that much treatment is sought outside of public health services. Several pilots and a country programme in Cambodia have also introduced the tests through community health workers (CHWs) (Bell et al., 2001, Harvey et al., 2008, Yeung et al., 2008). A major source of antimalarial treatment in many settings is private drug shops, and this has led to calls to consider including these drug shops in the scale up of RDTs (Moon, Pérez Casas, Kindermans, de Smet, & von Schoen-Angerer, 2009). There is limited evidence of the best way to scale-up RDTs in any sector, with evidence that public providers may continue to overprescribe antimalarials in spite of negative RDT results (Bisoffi et al., 2009, Hamer et al., 2007, Kyabayinze et al., 2010, Reyburn et al., 2007, Skarbinski et al., 2009). The context into which RDTs are introduced has been an important determinant of adherence to test results, with public sector workers holding a long established mindset of presumptive treatment that has been hard to leave behind (Chandler et al., 2008, Chandler et al., 2010). Pilots of more supportive packages for provider behaviour change, particularly supportive supervision, have been more effective in restricting antimalarials to parasite positive patients (D’Acremont, 2009, Hopkins, 2008, Msellem et al., 2009, Williams et al., 2008). There is less evidence of the effectiveness of RDTs in community level programmes, but findings so far suggest community volunteers are able to do tests when given suitable instructions (Harvey et al., 2008) and have adhered well to guidelines for testing and treatment (Counihan, 2009). In the Philippines, CHWs reported positive impacts of the tests on job satisfaction and standing in the community (Bell et al., 2001). In the scale up of RDTs in the periphery, implementers have stressed the need for extended initial training and continued supervision and training at the peripheral level. There is far less evidence about how RDTs are used when they are implemented in the private sector, with no published data on frequency of use or adherence to results.
Uganda has a policy of free health care and medicines at public health facilities and rapid diagnostic tests are in the process of being introduced at health centres across the country. However the public health care system has been plagued by stockouts in recent times. Perhaps related to this, an estimated 63 percent of medicines are procured from the private sector, mostly from drug shops (Rutebemberwa, Pariyo, Peterson, Tomson, & Kallander, 2009). The introduction of RDTs at drug shops therefore has the potential to make a significant contribution to targeting antimalarial drugs to those with malaria parasites. However, this contribution will be contingent upon how the tests are used, as well as the extent to which test results will affect treatment decisions. An understanding of the context into which the tests will be introduced is essential for framing analysis of the uptake and impacts of their introduction.
In this paper, we describe the context into which RDTs will be introduced in a peri-urban district in Uganda. We look at the position of drug shops for community members and the public health system and analyse the role of diagnostic tests in treatment decisions.
Section snippets
Setting and study sample
The results presented in this paper were collected as a formative research component prior to a randomized trial of the introduction of RDTs in registered private drug shops in the Mukono District of Uganda, a peri-urban area east of Kampala with a population of 850,900. This formative qualitative study was conducted in May to July 2009 with the aim to understand how people perceive the role of registered drug shops, and attitudes toward malaria treatment and diagnosis in drug shops in order to
Results
We start by describing the roles of drug shops for clients and for the public health system. We describe the liminal status of drug shops in this study: at once a shop and a clinic; legitimate and illegitimate; and trusted and distrusted. This forms the context for the second part of our results, which focuses on the role of diagnostic tests within the current use of antimalarials and laboratory tests. We describe how treatment of symptoms in practice is in effect a ‘diagnosis’, but how
At once a shop and a clinic
The registered drug shops in this study consisted of 1–2 rooms, with 1–2 staff serving at any one time. Most were located in or around trading centres and had the appearance of pharmacies, denoted with a blue cross, with medicines clearly on display behind the counter. Most were not connected to electricity or water and did not have refrigerators. Some displayed educational materials, and some drug shop workers wore white coats whilst others were smartly dressed.
Drug shops in our study were an
Malaria and its treatment, in practice
Participants in our study described malaria as an individual disease that is identifiable from your symptoms at previous episodes, for example,
‘Ok, for me when I suspect malaria, the signs I get are: headache, it’s too severe; and sour mouth. When I get that taste, and headache, I just know it’s malaria’. (R3, FGD#01 – women).
Symptoms most commonly reported by community members as indicative of them suffering with malaria, in order of frequency, were: joint pains, high fever, headache, stomach
Discussion
The idea of having malaria RDTs in drug shops was embraced by our study participants. However, our analysis of the context of care in this setting and the perception of the function of diagnostic tests suggests that RDTs could have limited impact on treatment decisions in the absence of efforts to support this new rationalisation for malaria treatment. At drug shops, malaria treatment was found to be synonymous with diagnosis. Diagnostic testing was deemed useful in theory, to satisfy curiosity
Conclusion
Drug shops are currently the first step in seeking treatment for malaria for many in Uganda. The introduction of RDTs into drug shops has the potential to drastically increase access to diagnostic testing. However, their introduction will be into an existing system of care where tests are not a core component of treatment decisions. This will require a thoughtful approach to the design of supporting interventions and careful monitoring and evaluation to assess processes and impacts of the tests
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the District Director of Health services Mukono District, Mr. Steven Kalake, Ms Charity Wamala, Ms Deborah Namisango, Joseph Mugisha and Dennise Kasenene, for data collection. We are grateful for the time and insights given by each of the study participants.
This study was funded by a grant from ACT Consortium at London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
References (39)
Self-care and the informal sale of drugs in south Cameroon
Social Science & Medicine
(1987)- et al.
Soft targets or partners in health? Retail pharmacies and their role in Tanzania’s malaria control program
Social Science & Medicine
(2010) - et al.
Agenda for an anthropology of pharmaceutical practice
Social Science & Medicine
(1994) Reification and the consciousness of the patient
Social Science & Medicine. Part B: Medical Anthropology
(1980)- et al.
Dispensary level pilot implementation of rapid diagnostic tests: an evaluation of RDT acceptance and usage by providers and patients – Tanzania, 2005
Malaria Journal
(2008) - et al.
A critical review of behavioral issues related to malaria control in sub-Saharan Africa: what contributions have social scientists made?
Social Science & Medicine
(2004) - et al.
Popular pills: Community drug use in Uganda
(1996) - et al.
Diagnosis of malaria in a remote area of the Philippines: comparison of techniques and their acceptance by health workers and the community
Bulletin of the World Health Organization
(2001) - et al.
Rapid malaria diagnostic tests vs. clinical management of malaria in rural Burkina Faso: safety and effect on clinical decisions. A randomized trial
Tropical Medicine & International Health
(2009) - et al.
Guidelines and mindlines: why do clinical staff over-diagnose malaria in Tanzania? A qualitative study
Malaria Journal
(2008)
How can malaria rapid diagnostic tests achieve their potential? A qualitative study of a trial at health facilities in Ghana
Malaria Journal
Malaria rapid diagnosis performance by community health workers, Zambia
Who are ‘Informal health providers’ and what do they do? Perspectives from medical Anthropology
Massive reduction of antimalarial prescription after rapid diagnostic test implementation in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
Time to move from presumptive malaria treatment to laboratory-confirmed diagnosis and treatment in African children with fever
PLoS Medicine
Medicine sellers and malaria treatment in sub-Saharan Africa: what do they do and how can their practice be improved?
The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
Quality information in field research: Training manual on practical communication skills for field researchers and project personnel. World health organization on behalf of the special programme for research and training in tropical diseases
Improved diagnostic testing and malaria treatment practices in Zambia
Journal of the American Medical Association
Improving community health worker use of malaria rapid diagnostic tests in Zambia: package instructions, job aid and job aid-plus-training
Malaria Journal
Cited by (62)
Life in the buffer zone: Social relations and surplus health workers in Uganda's medicines retail sector
2022, Social Science and MedicineCitation Excerpt :Anthropologists interested in knowledge and power documented the difference and outsider status of these largely unregulated, untrained medicine sellers, focusing on the difficulties that individuals had in maintaining legitimacy when they had no qualifications and/or no institutional belonging (Cross and Macgregor, 2010; Pinto 2004; Reynolds Whyte, 1992). Locally constituted rather than bio-medical power structures influenced those who were able to maintain their position in these crowded markets Shop keepers selling medicine occupied a liminal position within the health system (Chandler et al., 2011); those more firmly embedded within the formal public sector sought to maintain distinctions between themselves and these ‘other’ service providers (AUTHOR publication). The research on these local medicine markets has been amongst the most influential in terms of uptake of anthropological findings in public health (Goodman et al., 2007; Okeke et al., 2006; Alubo, 2001).
The anthropology of health systems: A history and review
2022, Social Science and MedicineCitation Excerpt :João Biehl (2013) describes how healthcare markets across “the clinic, the court, and the marketplace” play a role in Brazil (p. 421). The lines between public-private, legal-illegal, and formal-informal providers are often blurred (Chandler et al., 2011). There is a history of anthropological work on the relationships between drug reps and providers, showing how reciprocal relationships shape prescribing (Kamat and Nichter, 1998; Oldani, 2004).
Enhancing livestock vaccination decision-making through rapid diagnostic testing
2019, World Development PerspectivesCitation Excerpt :To scale up disease control to the community and national level, promoting compliance to early detection and preventative control strategies at the household level is necessary. While households value the prospects of receiving information to enhance vaccine matching capabilities, long-term declines in participation may result (Chandler et al., 2011; Dupas, Hoffmann, Kremer, & Zwane, 2016) if the vaccines produce sub-optimal protection despite testing. Similar to human health concerns (Newman-Toker, McDonald, & Meltzer, 2013), illustrating the tradeoffs between vaccination and other treatment strategies and emphasizing when the benefit to vaccinating with testing exceeds the benefit of not testing will provide households with the information to make individually optimal decisions, which may include not vaccinating.
Point-of-Care Testing for Anemia, Diabetes, and Hypertension: A Pharmacy-Based Model in Lima, Peru
2017, Annals of Global HealthCitation Excerpt :Previous studies have reported the benefits of including pharmacy workers in detection of diseases in low-resource settings globally where access to the traditional health system can be challenging.31-36 Most studies evaluating POC testing in pharmacies in low-resource settings have focused on communicable diseases, such as malaria and human immunodeficiency virus.35,37-39 However, a recent article on POC testing in high-income settings suggests pharmacy-based testing for chronic diseases can improve health outcomes while reducing societal costs.40
Point-of-care testing in private pharmacy and drug retail settings: a narrative review
2023, BMC Infectious Diseases