Table 3

Recommendations for surgical system strengthening in Brazil and globally for the Lancet indicators

IndicatorSurgical system strengthening in BrazilGlobal application of the Lancet indicators
Indicator 1:
Access to timely essential surgery
  • Facility-level data that look at surgical equipment, workforce and infrastructure are needed

  • Tools such as the WHO Situation Assessment Tool35 can be useful for determining facility-level capabilities

  • Look at operating room density/100 000 population as an adjunct indicator when basic parameters of access are met

Indicator 2:
Specialist surgical workforce density
  • Address large geographic disparities for SAO

  • Consider rural residency training in addition to rural medical education

  • Address the shortage of anaesthesia providers

  • Disaggregate the surgical workforce density by specialty to find nuances

  • Assess internal distribution to look for regional deficiencies

  • Use full-time equivalent of SAO in the public sector as an adjunct indicator

Indicator 3:
Surgical volume
  • Measure and report private surgical volume

  • Address geographic disparities in public sector volume

  • Monitor overuse as access continues to improve

  • Assess internal distribution to look for regional deficiencies

  • Monitor overuse by evaluating case-mix

Indicator 4:
Perioperative mortality rate
  • Ensure accurate reporting

  • Develop a national strategy for assessing and improving postoperative outcomes

  • Consider procedure-specific perioperative mortality rates to minimise variation in patient risk

Indicators 5 and 6:
Protection against impoverishing and catastrophic expenditure
  • Investigate what expenditures are being passed on to the patient

  • Expand financial risk protection beyond the cost of procedures

  • As an adjunct, consider patient-level analyses to disaggregate what contributes to out-of-pocket expenditure

  • Consider the effect of out-of-pocket expenditure on different income strata

  • SAO, surgeons, anaesthesiologists and obstetricians.